Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Melancholy: The Metamorphoses of Depression

Hélène Prigent
Review by: İdris Muxtarzadə16 September 20261 min read
An elegantly illustrated cultural history from the French Gallimard "Découvertes" series, tracing two thousand years of melancholy in Western culture.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers interested in topics at the intersection of art history, philosophy, and cultural history
  • Anyone who enjoys the short, richly illustrated "pocket encyclopedia" format (the Gallimard "Découvertes" series)
  • Readers who want a cultural-symbolic, rather than medical, history of melancholy
  • Anyone looking for a broad "history of ideas" journey from ancient Greek philosophy through the Renaissance and Romanticism
Not a Fit
  • Readers looking for current psychological/medical information on clinical depression — the book is written from a historical-cultural perspective and does not address modern diagnostics
  • Anyone expecting a deep scholarly citation apparatus — the book is written for a broad audience, with minimal academic footnoting
  • Readers who prefer a text-first format — in this series, images carry as much weight as the text itself
How Readers Rate It
Academic level 2.9/5 Average
Image-to-text ratio 3.7/5 Image-heavy
Historical scope 4.2/5 Broad
45 voters
Introduction and Chapter 1: "The Anatomy of Melancholy" — from black bile to genius
Covers the book's Introduction and Chapter 1 ("The Anatomy of Melancholy," pp. 12–29, ~18 pages, ~10% of the book); the remaining 5 chapters (the Devil/Saturn link in the Middle Ages, the Renaissance, Classicism/the Enlightenment, Romanticism, and the aftermath of Romanticism) are not covered here.

The book opens with a brief introduction — the word melancholy is presented as an ancient "monument" more than two thousand years old, onto which every era has layered new meaning; the author stresses that there is no single reality called "melancholy," only the history of the word and the layers of meaning it has accrued.

Chapter 1 ("The Anatomy of Melancholy") begins by tracing the word's roots to ancient Greece — "melankholia" derives from "khole" (bile) and "melas" (black), and was used as early as the 4th century BCE by Hippocrates (or his son-in-law Polybus) as part of the four-humors theory of the body (blood, yellow bile, black bile, phlegm).

The book shows that what "black bile" actually was has never been precisely established — the ancient Greeks associated it with dark vomit and the spleen, but the author emphasizes it remained an almost abstract substance, "never observed" directly, drawing its real power instead from the metaphorical weight it carried as a word.

Through mythological examples (tragic heroes like Heracles and Ajax), the book shows that melancholy was linked from the start to both illness and tragic grandeur — in Sophocles' account, Ajax becomes a symbolic figure who sheds "black blood" before taking his own life.

The chapter's most notable section is devoted to the text known as "Problem XXX," attributed to Aristotle — the first text to interpret melancholy not as an illness but as a mark of genius, attempting to explain why so many outstanding figures in philosophy, statecraft, poetry, and the arts were visibly melancholic.

The chapter thus lays out the book's core thesis early: melancholy was never merely a medical category — it also lived in parallel as a cultural metaphor tied to creativity and genius, a dual legacy the book traces through its remaining chapters (the Middle Ages, the Renaissance, Romanticism).

Reading Experience
  • The classic format of the Gallimard "Découvertes" series — every page pairs text with large, high-quality reproductions of artworks (ancient ceramics, Renaissance engravings)
  • The main text is written in a chronological, encyclopedic tone, avoiding academic jargon in favor of an accessible, warm register for a general audience
  • Short factual sidebars and quotations (from sources like Hippocrates and Sophocles) run alongside the main text on every page
  • The book closes (per the series' standard structure) with a "Documents" section of primary-source excerpts and an extensive index
If You Liked This
Anatomy of MelancholyRobert Burton

The classic, far more voluminous original 17th-century treatise on the same subject

Madness and CivilizationMichel Foucault

A similar historical-cultural analysis of the concepts of madness and depression

Spoiler
Where does the book go from here?
⚠️ The general direction, based on the chapter titles, is revealed here.

Chapter 2 traces how melancholy was linked to "acedia" (spiritual sloth/demonic temptation) in early Christianity and to the planet Saturn in the Middle Ages; Chapter 3 shows how, in the Renaissance (via Ficino and Dürer's famous engraving "Melencolia I"), melancholy was reunited with genius and enjoyed its own "golden age."

The remaining chapters trace melancholy losing its prestige during Classicism/the Enlightenment, becoming central again in Romanticism (through the exaltation of the imagination), and being increasingly reduced, after the 19th century, to a mere phenomenon of memory — the book follows this evolution visually to the end through the work of painters like Delacroix, Friedrich, Munch, Redon, and Hopper.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A practical book by the authors of «Chicken Soup for the Soul» that presents ten «focus strategies» for reaching goals in business and personal life, mixing motivation with business experience. In the first strategy read, the strongest side is the way it explains how habits shape the future through simple metaphors (the links of a chain, the «no exceptions» policy) and the concrete «Action Steps» at the end of each section. The weak side is that testimonials such as «hundreds of thousands of clients» and «I raised my income by 246%» cannot be verified, the results rest on selected success stories, and the book has a good deal of advertising in it.
3.5 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
The Power of Focus

The Power of Focus

Jack Canfield, Mark Victor Hansen, Les Hewitt · Non-fiction
Reviews
Virginia Giuffre's posthumous memoir telling in the first person of childhood abuse, trafficking, escape and legal struggle. In the editor's note and introduction that were read, the strongest side is that the way the book was prepared and verified is openly shown and the author's reason for speaking is clearly explained. The weak side is that the subject is extremely heavy and that the conflicting positions of the parties (family, husband, the accused) in the editor's note make the book's reliability contested. An important but very hard-to-read testimony.
4.0 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Nobody’s Girl

Nobody’s Girl

Virginia Roberts Giuffre · Non-fiction
Reviews
A landmark of American literary naturalism — the origin story of a ruthless, morally unconflicted financial genius, loosely based on the real life of streetcar magnate Charles Yerkes, told in Dreiser's dry, almost sociological prose.
4.2 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
The Financier

The Financier

Theodore Dreiser · Classics
Reviews
A sociology classic that exposes, with rigorous academic precision, the hidden mechanisms that make male domination look "natural."
4.4 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Masculine Domination

Masculine Domination

Pierre Bourdieu · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text