Blood Orange
Good Fit
- Readers who enjoy psychological thrillers built around unreliable, flawed female protagonists
- Anyone looking for a story that braids courtroom drama with domestic crisis
- Readers who don't mind watching a protagonist unravel through her own choices
- Fans of the "unreliable narrator" device and fragmented, emotionally charged prose
Not a Fit
- Readers wanting a likeable, morally steady protagonist — Alison is knowingly self-destructive
- Anyone expecting a fast-paced, action-driven thriller — the book moves at a slow, atmospheric pace
- Readers who prefer procedural courtroom detail over an emotion-focused narrative style
The novel opens with an unsettling, unattributed "performance" scene — a carefully staged ritual before a camera, symbolized by a silk scarf and a sliced orange, hovering on the line between danger and control. The scene explains the book's title, but whose perspective it belongs to is deliberately left unclear until much later.
The story then shifts to Alison, a criminal barrister who lands her first murder brief on a Friday. A celebratory drink with colleagues turns into another chapter of a tense, recurring affair with her married colleague Patrick; drunk, she sleeps with him on her office desk and spends the night in her own chair.
The next morning, her young daughter Matilda finding her at the office exposes the cracks in Alison's family life — her husband Carl, a therapist, is losing patience, while Alison keeps apologizing and repeating the same behavior. These early scenes establish how her professional success and personal self-destruction are advancing side by side.
Alison finally opens the case file: 44-year-old Madeleine Smith was arrested after her husband Edwin, a partner at an American asset management firm, was found stabbed fifteen times in the neck and torso while asleep in bed. Edwin was killed in his sleep — his body shows no defensive wounds. Madeleine was found sitting on the floor beside the body, entirely calm, and has offered no explanation.
Alison's first meeting with Madeleine follows — living under strict bail conditions at her sister Francine's house, Madeleine is outwardly composed and guarded, revealing almost nothing about her marriage. Their fourteen-year-old son James is confirmed to have been away at boarding school for the weekend, but Madeleine's silence leaves Alison — and the reader — with the sense that something is being withheld.
- A first-person, present-tense unreliable-narrator technique — shifts between feeling and memory happen without warning
- Quoted case documents (press summaries, initial statements) intercut with Alison's personal narration, linking her two parallel "cases" — the legal one and the personal one
- Specific London geography (Archway, Gray's Inn Road, Holloway) is used to map Alison's inner state
- Bodily sensations like smell and taste (cigarette smoke, wine, sweat) constantly recall guilt and addiction
A similarly tense unreliable female narrator built around a disintegrating marriage
A similar structure combining a murder mystery with psychological/therapeutic investigation
Madeleine's statement reveals years of abuse by her husband Edwin: humiliation, being made to eat food off the floor, kicks. Then a new possibility emerges: the one who wielded the knife may have been her son James, not Madeleine. Alison sets out the options, but Madeleine flatly refuses to let her son be drawn in.
Alison finally sees her husband Carl, a therapist, for who he is. She finds a hidden camera at home and catches Carl watching a video of himself abusing her while she was unconscious — on nights she had thought she had simply passed out from drink. At that moment Carl is in the middle of an act of erotic asphyxiation and in critical danger. Alison sits and waits, and only then calls the ambulance and the police. The papers call it «another Stephen Milligan case», and police find videos of other women on Carl's computer.
In the «Five Months Later» epilogue Alison is living with her daughter Matilda, and the two are about to get cats. A new prosecutor accepts Madeleine's plea, and in court Alison asks for the lightest possible sentence in view of the whole chain of events. Alison will never tell the police what she did that night.
If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
