Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Paganism — The Ancient Nature Faith

Robby Silver
Review by: İdris Muxtarzadə28 September 20261 min read
A pocket book that paints a wide picture, from pre-Christian nature religions to today's Wicca and Druid movements: the neopaganism chapter is interesting and informative, but the text at times reads like compiled notes, some facts and names are wrong, and the Wiccan principles are reproduced almost verbatim without any critical filter.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who want a quick idea of what modern movements like Wicca, Druidry and Ásatrú are
  • Those drawn to pagan culture through fantasy, mythology and historical TV series
  • Beginners in the history of religions looking for a simple introduction
  • Readers of the series' «Shamanism», «Deism» and «Shinto» volumes
Not a Fit
  • Readers expecting academic accuracy and source criticism
  • Those looking for a critical, sociological view of neopagan movements
  • Anyone tired of scattered chapters that don't fully connect
How Readers Rate It
Scope 3.7/5 Broad
Depth 2.6/5 Average
Critical view 2.5/5 Average
40 voters
Chapter 5 — «Neopaganism»
The book's fifth chapter (pp. 83–94, about 9% of the book) was read and analysed. The introduction on the origin of religion and the chapters on classical paganism, mystery religions, esotericism, symbolism and dying-and-rising gods are not analysed in detail in this review.

The chapter opens with the etymology of «pagan»: the Latin word meaning «villager, non-urban» began to be used in the 4th century, in a Roman Empire that had adopted Christianity as its official religion, to disparage communities far from the cities that still worshipped the forces of nature. It then gives the distinction between «paleo-paganism», «meso-paganism» and «neopaganism», noting that this classification is Christian in origin and ignores the other monotheistic religions — a good critical touch for a pocket book.

The most interesting part is the sociological context of neopaganism. The book says the 19th-century prediction that secularisation would wipe out religion has not come true; since the 1960s a turn described as a «new religious awakening» or «the revenge of God» has begun, but it is individual rather than communal religiosity. There is a nice comparison here too: customs such as Muslims tying cloth to wishing trees or jumping over fire are old pagan traces kept alive by communal bonds, whereas neopaganism is the response of lonely urban individuals whose communal ties have weakened.

The core teachings of neopaganism are listed as bullet points: nature is sacred, every being has a divine aspect, the soul lives on after death and is reborn, one must encounter the divine face to face without intermediaries, ecological responsibility matters, there is no belief in a messiah, and a protective circle is drawn in rituals. The list is clear and useful, but it sometimes blurs which group it refers to — for example, the same list says «we have no dogma» while presenting a definite belief system.

Wicca stands at the centre of the chapter. The book explains how this movement, which spread in England after Gerald Gardner's 1954 book «Witchcraft Today» and became popular in America in the 1960s, differs from witchcraft; its ethical principle «do what you will, so long as it harms none»; the «Law of Threefold Return» holding that good and evil come back threefold; the «Summerland» where souls rest; the pentagram; and covens of thirteen. The «13 Principles» of American Wiccans are given in full — but without any commentary or context, almost like promotional material.

The section on Druidry is also interesting, but here errors multiply. The Druids are called «bearers of a Protagorean philosophy», whereas ancient sources usually link them with Pythagorean ideas (the transmigration of souls). The Ásatrú movement is spelt «Asartu» and eclectic paganism «Eecleetic». On Stonehenge there is an interesting correction: the last megaliths were built around 1400 BC, while the Celts arrived in Britain around 500–600 BC, so attributing these structures to the Druids is historically difficult. The reference to the Asterix and Obelix comics brings the subject closer to the reader.

Overall this chapter is the most up-to-date and readable part of the book: it tries to present neopaganism not as a fad or a «witchcraft» cliché but as a reaction to modernity, urban loneliness and ecological anxiety. Yet unsourced figures (a hundred thousand neopagans in the US, the claim of the «fastest-growing religion»), typesetting errors and the lack of a critical approach to the principles it presents make it only a first source of information.

Reading Experience
  • Teachings and principles listed as bullet points
  • Short biographies in the margins (e.g. Gerald Gardner)
  • Colour illustrations and images of symbols
  • Bibliography and the translator's sources at the end
Content Warning
Contains descriptions of witchcraft, magic and human-sacrifice ritualsSome names and facts are misspelt or wrong; figures are unsourced
If You Liked This
Shamanism: The Discovery of Spirit and BodyTaymas Elemes

Explains one of the oldest forms of pagan belief — reviewed on our site

Shinto — Spirits of the AncestorsRobby Silver

From the same series, on an animist nature religion that is still alive today — reviewed on our site

The Handy Religion Answer BookJohn Renard

A broad question-and-answer overview of world religions — reviewed on our site

Spoiler
How does this part end?
⚠️ Druidism: Stonehenge and the Celts

The chapter ends with the section on druidism: druids are called «bearers of the Protagorean philosophy», and about Stonehenge it is noted that the last of the megaliths was raised in the 1400s BC while the Celts reached Britain in the 500s–600s BC. The chapter tries to present neopaganism not as a fashion or a «witchcraft» stereotype but as a reaction to modernity and ecological anxiety.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A comprehensive guide to going vegan by Alexandra Jamieson, the health coach and chef known from the documentary 'Super Size Me': meal planning, shopping, the kitchen, restaurants and travel, pregnancy, children, athletes and more than 60 recipes. True to the 'For Dummies' format, everything is broken into short sections, lists and icons. The practical side is strong and it rightly stresses key points such as B12, but unscientific claims about 'detox' and an occasionally preachy tone weaken its credibility.
3.5 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Living Vegan For Dummies

Living Vegan For Dummies

Alexandra Jamieson · Non-fiction
Reviews
A broad, encyclopedic self-help book by Melahat Eren, covering dozens of topics from self-discovery to financial literacy in a collection of general, widely-applicable advice.
3.9 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
A Better You

A Better You

Melahat Eren · Non-fiction
Reviews
A collection of essays in which an American blogger who lives with depression, anxiety disorder, self-harm and rheumatoid arthritis talks about all of it with dark humour. Its greatest strength is sincerity: the author neither romanticises nor hides mental illness and tells the reader “you are not alone”. The final essays and the story of “the 24 file” are genuinely moving. The weak side: much of the humour relies on absurd, sexual and crude jokes, many chapters read simply as funny blog posts, and the book's overall rhythm is scattered. Some of the wordplay is lost in the Turkish translation. For readers who enjoy this kind of humour it is both funny and supportive — but it is not to everyone's taste.
3.8 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Furiously Happy

Furiously Happy

Jenny Lawson · Non-fiction
Reviews
Forty short essays by a French Lacanian psychoanalyst that explain obsessional neurosis not through a list of symptoms but through small stories, films and books. Its strongest side is that doubt is shown not as a «sign of illness» but as the way a person takes a place in the world, and that examples such as Leone and Freud's «Rat Man» case give a rich reading. Its weak side is the heavy Lacanian terminology (jouissance, «the Other», structure) and the complete absence of practical advice: a reader suffering from OCD will find no path to treatment here.
3.6 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
An Infinite Doubt: The Obsessional in 40 Lessons

An Infinite Doubt: The Obsessional in 40 Lessons

Alain Abelhauser · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text