Surely You’re Joking, Mr. Feynman!
Good Fit
- Readers who want to meet the human side of a scientist, away from dry biography, told with real humor
- Fans of memoirs that celebrate curiosity, trial-and-error, and self-reliance
- Readers looking to get acquainted with a classic of popular-science literature
- Readers who prefer books made of short, self-contained stories
Not a Fit
- Readers looking for systematic, textbook-style physics content — the book is made of biographical anecdotes
- Readers expecting a linear, chronological classic memoir — the chapters are independent stories
- Readers wanting a serious, formally-toned scientific biography — the book is deliberately light and jokey
- Readers sensitive to every aspect of Feynman's personal life (some later chapters include racy episodes)
The book opens with the small home laboratory Feynman built at age eleven or twelve — shelves in a cardboard box, a homemade panel of light bulbs, even a burglar alarm he wired himself. This loving, detailed description immediately signals the trait that will define his whole life: the urge to take anything apart, understand it, and rebuild it.
During the Depression, families couldn't afford to have their radios repaired, so young Feynman starts fixing old radios cheaply. He tells this plainly, without bragging — this isn't the portrait of a boy genius, but the story of a kid who gradually gets good through trial and error.
The episode that gives the book its title happens right in this chapter: a poor man calls Feynman to fix his radio; the moment it's switched on it makes a terrifying roar, then calms down and plays normally. Without touching it, Feynman paces the room thinking, and concludes the tubes are warming up in the wrong order — he swaps them, and the radio plays perfectly silent from then on.
The man finds this 'unbelievable' — that a small boy could solve the problem without even touching the set, just by thinking — and starts telling everyone that Feynman 'fixes radios by thinking.' The episode is a miniature portrait of both the book's title and Feynman's entire scientific method: observation, logical deduction, then practical verification.
The chapter then turns to his growing reputation as a puzzle-solver — riddles no other student at school could crack being brought to him, and a girl at MIT trying to stump him with a 'bubonic plague' riddle, only for Feynman to recognize the story and land on the right answer.
What's notable here is that Feynman never frames his own successes as 'genius' — he consistently credits persistence, prior experience, or plain luck instead. This humble, self-deprecating tone sets the voice that carries through the entire book.
The chapter also nostalgically recalls how simple the technology of the era was — radio circuits were open, every part visible and understandable. Feynman makes the point deliberately: as complexity grows, the ability to understand things 'by hand' shrinks.
The chapter closes with a smaller episode that shows his persistence — spending an entire afternoon tracking down a resistor that showed no visible sign of burning. It crystallizes one of the book's central messages: what set Feynman apart wasn't inspiration so much as the sheer refusal to let a puzzle go.
The same author's plain-language explanation of quantum electrodynamics
The follow-up memoir to this book
Another classic of popular science, with a similarly plain, explanatory style
Part Two ("Princeton Years") recounts Feynman's famous pranks during his graduate studies — including the episode that gives the book its title, and the party trick where pure logical deduction lets him draw a stranger's 'cat map' and startle her.
Part Three ("Feynman, the Bomb, and the Military") covers his role in the Manhattan Project, his hobby of cracking safes at Los Alamos, and his running jokes about the security of classified documents.
Part Four ("From Cornell to Caltech, by way of Brazil") describes his teaching stint in Brazil, his critique of the rote-learning education system he found there, and his non-scientific passions like dancing and playing the bongos.
The final part ("The World of a Physicist") shows a more mature Feynman — closing with his views on science politics, prizes (including his ambivalence about the Nobel), and his critique of what he calls 'cargo cult science': research that looks scientific on the surface but lacks real methodology.
Coverage. This review covers only the opening story of Part One (“He Fixes Radios by Thinking!”, ≈3%); the remaining four parts are not covered (only their topics are summarized above).
Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.
If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.