Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Novel

Barbarian Mine

In English: Barbarian Mine: Ice Planet Barbarians, Book 4 (Barbar Madeni; the Turkish title mistakes «Mine» for «a mine»)
Ruby Dixon
Review by: Cavid Mehdiyev13 October 20261 min read
The fourth book of the series about human women living with blue, horned barbarians on another planet is the adventure of Rukh, a barbarian who has lived alone and half forgotten how to speak, and Harlow, who has been saved from cancer. Its strongest side is a sweet romance built on language learning, warm humour and the way family and community make sense at the end. Its weakest side is the question of consent at the start, when Rukh knocks Harlow out, carries her off and ties her hands and feet (the hero is softened when he later learns the word «no» and stops), the many detailed sex scenes, and the coarse, wrong word choices of the unofficial translation. Entertaining for readers of the genre, not for everyone.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Adult readers who like erotic fantasy romance with a barbarian-mate theme on an ice planet
  • Those who enjoy a love story between two characters with a language and communication barrier
  • Readers of the earlier books in the series who are curious about Harlow and Rukh's story
Not a Fit
  • Readers bothered by sex scenes, coarse word choices and a possessive male lead
  • Those who do not accept romances that begin with abduction and initial forced captivity
How Readers Rate It
Readability 4.0/5 Smooth
Tension 2.8/5 Average
Emotional weight 2.9/5 Average
40 voters
The opening: a girl cutting trees for a travois on Not-Hoth and the lone sa-khui
Pp. 5–28 · about 9% of the book (the recap of earlier volumes, chapter 1 and the start of chapter 2). What follows the word «No»: the exchange of names, the ship crash and the first fire (pp. 28–38) is in the spoiler section; the remaining ≈87% is not opened in this review.

The book is the fourth volume of the «Ice Planet Barbarians» series and opens with a short recap of earlier volumes. Human women abducted from Earth are held in an alien ship's cage; after an escape the ship crash-lands on an icy planet called Not-Hoth. There the women meet the tribe of large, blue, horned sa-khui. Every sa-khui has a symbiotic being called a «khui» in the chest: one without it falls ill from the air and dies within a week. When a compatible mate is found the khui sings a song in the chest called «resonance», which leads to mating.

Chapter 1 begins in Harlow's voice. She is a woman from Houston who, on Earth, was preparing for chemotherapy for an inoperable brain tumour. Now she has woken from a tube on an alien planet; according to the ship's medical computer she no longer has cancer. At present she is cutting soft «pink» trees to make a travois, a drag-sled, to help two wounded sa-khui, Aehako and Haeden. Her friend Kira has been taken to the ship. Harlow is human-sized; on this planet everything is «a bit too big» for her.

While cutting trees Harlow hears the crunch of snow behind her. Someone is near. She takes a blow to the back of the head and passes out. The attacker is an alien, a lone sa-khui: Rukh. From Rukh's voice we read that he lost his father when little and has lived alone since; he has forgotten many words. For several days he has been tracking two furred beings travelling with the «bad ones»; the orange-red «mane» of one has enchanted him.

Rukh carries Harlow to his cave. When he sees she is a «female» he is amazed: her body seems «pleasant» to him and he does not know what that means. He binds the wound on Harlow's head with a medicinal herb and says «this female is mine now, I will kill anything that tries to take her». Rukh's thinking is simple and possessive, but he tries not to hurt the woman.

When Harlow wakes her head aches and she hears the song of «resonance» in her chest. She understands that her khui has «chosen» her to mate with a man she does not know. In the cave a crouched, naked, dirt-covered sa-khui sits sharpening a knife. Harlow addresses him in English and in the old sa-khui tongue and gets no reply. She asks about Aehako and Haeden. The man is silent. Harlow snatches the knife and tries to run; Rukh catches her in the snow, her tunic comes undone, and from the eyes of the man looking at her chest Harlow understands what may happen. Between fear and attraction she says «No».

Reading Experience
  • The story is told in alternating chapters by Harlow and Rukh, in first person present tense
  • Language learning and words rendered as heard in the garbled dialogue («Dunwannagohbak», «Lemmegoh») are the comic side of the romance
  • There are many sex scenes and physical descriptions, and the coarse word choices get heavier still in the Turkish translation
  • Between chapters there are short section breaks marked «- - -», and at the end come the author's note and advertisements for other books in the series
  • The main plot line is simple: meeting, closeness, pregnancy, risk, return to the tribe and the forming of a family
Content Warning
A book for adults (18+): detailed sex scenes (masturbation, oral sex, postpartum intimacy) and coarse word choicesThe story begins with abduction and forced captivity: Rukh knocks Harlow out, carries her off and ties her hands and feet for a night; the hero is softened by his later understanding of the word «no» and his stopping, and by Harlow's own advances, but the episode may be problematicA possessive mate bond («she is mine») and the thought «I will kill anyone who comes near» are romanticisedThe book carries heavy subjects: pregnancy complications, childbirth, danger to a child, animal hunting and Harlow's earlier brain tumour; the Turkish translation looks unofficial
If You Liked This
Barbarian's MateRuby Dixon

The first book of the series, the main introduction to the planet and the sa-khui tribe

Barbarian LoverRuby Dixon

The preceding book of the series: the story of Kira and Aehako, the background to the events at the start of this book

Fifty Shades of GreyE. L. James

Another famous erotic romance: a possessive male lead and open sex scenes

Spoiler
The end of the 9%: the first word, the first fire and the falling ship
⚠️ Pp. 28–38: Rukh's reaction to «No», the crashing ship and the first understanding. Do not open it if you do not want to know.

Rukh knows this word: his father once taught it to him. To say «No» means «stop». He stops, letting the girl pull her furs back. At that same moment a black, disc-like ship appears in the sky, strikes the mountain and explodes. Harlow screams «Kira is on it!» Rukh, thinking she wants to run again, carries her to the cave and ties her hands and feet with straps for the night; he does not want to «lose his property».

In the morning Harlow wakes bound and shivering. Rukh unties her and shows her a spot in the snow for a toilet; Harlow sees that the smoke of the ship's crash is still visible above the mountain. Kira is dead, Aehako and Haeden are most likely dead too; she is the only survivor. Then the two exchange names: «Harlow» and «Rukh». Harlow knows how to make fire, gathers dvisti dung and lights her first hearth in the cave, and teaches Rukh the word «fire». So the first language bridge is built between two people with almost no words.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
David Cox's book in the «For Dummies» series explaining creative thinking in plain language with practical exercises. In the first chapter that was read, the strongest side is finding creativity in everyday life (the pen, the printing press, a film idea) and getting the reader out of the thought «I'm not creative». The weak side is the tone of general advice in some parts, that some examples are limited to Western culture and that scientific claims are not given precise sources. A good start for those seeking a simple introduction to creative thinking.
3.4 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Creative Thinking For Dummies

Creative Thinking For Dummies

David Cox · Non-fiction
Reviews
Written by a medical student in their early twenties, this worldwide bestseller of popular science explains the gut — our body's most "underrated" organ, which in fact runs two-thirds of our immune system — in a witty, accessible voice.
4.4 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Gut

Gut

Giulia Enders · Non-fiction
Reviews
A slow-burn, atmosphere-heavy opening that shows how legend gets made and how far the truth can drift once it passes through enough mouths.
4.5 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Blood of Elves

Blood of Elves

Andrzej Sapkowski · Fantasy
Reviews
Sherlock Holmes's second novel: a daring opening with a cocaine syringe, sharp deduction scenes, a treasure mystery from India and Watson's love story make it an atmospheric classic that still reads fast today; only the colonial-era stereotypes may trouble a modern reader.
4.3 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
The Sign of the Four

The Sign of the Four

Sir Arthur Conan Doyle · Classics
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text