Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

The Body Keeps the Score

In English: The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma
Bessel A. van der Kolk
Review by: İdris Muxtarzadə08 October 20261 min read
One of the most-read books in the trauma field, examining the effect of trauma on brain, mind and body and methods beyond traditional medication and talk therapy (EMDR, yoga, neurofeedback, theatre). Its strongest side is that the clinical stories draw the reader in from the start and that it shows trauma is not a «problem of will» but a physiological change. Its weak side is its size (more than 460 pages), the differing levels of evidence for some treatment methods and the author's strong, sometimes one-sided stance.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who want to learn, in scientific but story-driven language, how trauma affects the body and emotions
  • Psychologists, students, teachers and social workers who work with people who have lived through trauma
  • Anyone trying to understand the roots of seemingly unexplained rage, numbness and tension in themselves or someone close
Not a Fit
  • Readers who want a ready-made step-by-step self-help programme: the book describes treatment routes but is not a course
  • Anyone currently in the middle of their own trauma who cannot safely read heavy descriptions: the war and child abuse accounts are very hard
  • Readers who want a short scientific summary with full statistics: the book rests on clinical stories and the author's experience
How Readers Rate It
Readability 3.5/5 Average
Depth 4.0/5 Deep
Practical advice 3.1/5 Average
40 voters
Introduction and chapter 1 «Lessons from Vietnam veterans»: Tom, Bill and the Rorschach test
Read: the Introduction «Confronting trauma» and chapter 1 of part one «Lessons from Vietnam Veterans» in full (approx. pp. 1–21) — about 5% of the book.

The introduction gives the author's basic claim in a few sentences: we want to leave trauma behind, but the basic parts of our brain (deep beneath the rational brain) are not good at denial; even the smallest sign of danger sets off the damaged circuits and raises stress hormones. Van der Kolk writes that three new fields of science — neuroscience, developmental psychopathology and interpersonal neurobiology — show trauma as real physiological changes in the brain; behaviours are not «moral failings, lack of will or bad character» but changes in the brain. This sentence also sets the moral stance of the book.

The author lists three aims: top-down processing (talking, reconnecting with others), medication or other technologies that stop the inappropriate alarm reaction, and a bottom-up approach — letting the body have deep visceral experiences. «I have no single favourite method», he says, and presents the book both as a guide and as an invitation to society to prevent trauma.

Chapter 1 tells the first working day in July 1978 at the Boston Veterans Administration clinic. While he is hanging the reproduction of Breughel's «The Blind Leading the Blind» in his new office, a large man in a stained three-piece suit, hungover, with a copy of «Soldier of Fortune» under his arm, walks in: Tom. A former Marine in Vietnam, now a lawyer with two sons, but noise, fireworks and summer greenery drive him mad; he is afraid of his family because he behaves like a «monster» towards them; at night he has nightmares of the ambush in the paddy field and of dead children.

The author links Tom's story to his own childhood: his father was sent to a concentration camp for being an outspoken anti-Nazi, his uncle was a prisoner working on the Kwai bridge, both spoke rarely but had uncontrollable fits of rage. In the first session the author does what doctors usually do: he focuses on the nightmares and prescribes a drug. Two weeks later Tom says he has not taken the pills: «if the nightmares go I will have abandoned my friends; I must be the living memorial of my friends who died in Vietnam». This sentence determines the author's whole later professional life.

The rest of the chapter is divided into several small lessons. Tom's ambush: Alex and the whole platoon are killed; next day Tom goes to a village, kills children and rapes a woman — the «good, honourable, trustworthy part of himself» is lost for ever. «Numbing»: Tom tries to love his family but «lives behind a glass wall»; he comes alive only in a murder case («like being a warrior»). Bill, a former doctor, sees the children dead in Vietnam when his baby cries; colleagues think him psychotic, but the author says «this man suffers from his memories». On the second Rorschach card Bill sees the «dead child»; 16 of 21 veterans react as if reliving trauma and 5 see nothing — both groups have lost imagination.

Reading Experience
  • Each chapter opens with a clinical story and then the scientific explanation follows
  • The author uses his own family history and professional path as a personal bond
  • Concrete experiments such as the Rorschach test make abstract claims concrete
  • The language is in a tone that explains scientific terms with simple examples yet does not avoid heavy subjects
Content Warning
The book contains descriptions of war crimes, child abuse, rape and violence; it may be triggering for the readerNot all treatment methods are proven to the same degree; the book is no substitute for professional therapySome parts of the book are loaded with neuroscience terms
If You Liked This
Trauma and RecoveryJudith Herman

A classic of trauma psychology, with a historical and social view

Waking the TigerPeter A. Levine

On trauma staying in the body and body-oriented healing

What Happened to You?Bruce D. Perry, Oprah Winfrey

A plainer conversation about understanding trauma through the question «what happened to you?»

Spoiler
How does chapter 1 end?
⚠️ The veteran groups and the 1980 PTSD diagnosis.

The clinic fills with veterans; the author sets up groups of young Vietnam veterans and WWII veterans. In the first session, after half an hour of silence, one tells of a helicopter crash and the others come alive and feel a sense of «unit» with one another again. The veterans give the author a Marine uniform and later a 1940s GI wristwatch. The author concludes: after trauma the world divides into «those who know and those who don't».

In 1980 Chaim Shatan and Robert Lifton propose a new diagnosis at the American Psychiatric Association: post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). It finally names the veterans' symptoms and sets off an explosion in the search for research and treatment. Inspired by the new diagnosis, the author proposes at the VA a study of the biology of traumatic memories: is the memory of people with PTSD different from others'?

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A drama set in San Francisco in the early 1960s that drags a family secret into the courtroom: the war hero Luke Carey tries to rescue his 14-year-old daughter, who is caught up in a killing. Its strongest points are the psychological portrait of the artist mother, her daughter and the formidable grandmother, and the tension of the court chapters. Its weaknesses are a conventional 1960s outlook, long flashbacks and a book that does not sufficiently condemn the sexual abuse of a child.
3.4 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Where Love Has Gone

Where Love Has Gone

Harold Robbins · Novel
Reviews
A humorous detective-horror novel built on a translator's getting to know her neighbours after moving into a new flat in an old apartment block in Istanbul's Kadıköy. Its strongest side is the colourful neighbours, the chatty tone and the smile produced by a heroine, translating Agatha Christie, who sees herself as a detective. Its weak side is the slow build-up of tension in the first part and the length of the neighbour introductions.
3.6 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
The Berliner Building

The Berliner Building

Yaprak Öz · Novel
Reviews
A social-psychological novel set in Ankara: the limping locksmith Can, his womanizing, boastful friend Samet and Ayla between them. Its strongest qualities are the heroes' bold monologues on love, disability and «taboo» and the lively details of the minibus and shop world. Its weaknesses are the characters' long philosophical speeches, repeated scenes, the crudeness of its attitude to women and a dramatic ending that arrives hurriedly.
2.9 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Taboo: The Book of Womanizing

Taboo: The Book of Womanizing

M. Mehmet Ünver · Novel
Reviews
A lively, candid and scientifically very reliable book by an archaeologist who led Oxford's radiocarbon laboratory, about the other human groups that shared the Earth with us over the last 300,000 years — Neanderthals, Denisovans, the “Hobbits”, Homo erectus. Its greatest strength is that the discoveries are told from the inside by someone who took part in them: the story of “Denny”, the girl with a Neanderthal mother and a Denisovan father, found among thousands of bone fragments in Siberia's Denisova Cave, is genuinely thrilling. The weak side: some chapters get heavy with long technical explanations of laboratory methods. The Turkish translation reads smoothly. One of the best recent books for anyone interested in human evolution.
4.4 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
The World Before Us

The World Before Us

Tom Higham · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text