The Man in the High Castle
Good Fit
- Readers who enjoy alternate history, especially "what if the Axis won?" scenarios
- Anyone who prefers the psychological texture of daily life under occupation over a fast-moving plot
- Readers curious about Dick's philosophical science fiction and its recurring "what is reality?" theme
- Fans of slowly-interweaving, multi-protagonist novel structures
Not a Fit
- Readers looking for classic action/adventure-paced science fiction — the novel moves through interior thought and dialogue rather than espionage or combat set pieces
- Anyone who prefers a single, clear narrative line — the four or five parallel character threads can feel a little scattered at first
- Readers expecting every question clearly answered by a single, unambiguous ending — Dick's style typically preserves ambiguity
The novel lays out its worldbuilding before its plot, through everyday scenes: Robert Childan receives a humiliating phone call from Mr. Tagomi first thing in the morning, over a failure to source an American antique (a Mickey Mouse clock). This brief scene establishes, in a single stroke, the master-subject dynamic and the daily small humiliations of Americans living under occupation.
The Frank Frink thread introduces a different kind of pressure — he is secretly Jewish, living under a false identity, and is fired after a confrontation with his harsh boss. His decision to pursue his own jewelry-making talent as an independent craftsman, rather than staying hidden, introduces the novel's theme of small acts of self-expression under authoritarian rule.
The Juliana Frink thread unfolds in the neutral Rocky Mountain zone — she is a judo instructor who has just spent the night with Joe Cinnadella, a mysterious Italian war veteran. Joe's Iron Cross medal and his memories of the North African campaign humanize the "winning side" while filling the portrait with unsettling detail, including his hatred of the British.
The scene where Juliana discovers the banned book Joe has brought with him — Hawthorne Abendsen's "The Grasshopper Lies Heavy" — opens the novel's metafictional core: a banned science-fiction novel imagining a world where the Allies won (though one where Britain, not the US, is the dominant power — different even from the history we know).
In a parallel thread, Mr. Tagomi meets a mysterious businessman from neutral Sweden, Mr. Baynes, whose true purpose is never revealed here — but the tense, philosophical exchange between them (touching on racism, the concept of "uselessness," and Japan's wartime decision to protect Jews in Shanghai) subtly reveals moral differences between the two occupying regimes.
Small details scattered between chapters — four hours of daily television broadcasts in Germany but none yet in the Pacific States; Bob Hope broadcasting jokes about Göring from the safety of Canada; ordinary people casually debating who will become Führer after Hitler — show where the novel's real power lies: not in grand political events, but in how people adapt to this strange normalcy.
- A structure that shifts between four or five characters' points of view, gradually weaving them together
- Worldbuilding information is never delivered as exposition — it is embedded in characters' everyday stream of thought
- The "book within a book" device (The Grasshopper Lies Heavy) creates a metafictional layer — the reader encounters a doubled alternate history
- The I Ching (Book of Changes) recurs as a symbolic device characters use to make decisions
Another Nazi-victory alternate history, though paced more like a detective thriller
A similar approach to the rise of fascism in America, seen through everyday family life
Baynes's real name is Rudolf Wegener, here on a secret mission. When he meets the Japanese General Tedeki in Tagomi's office, German S.D. men burst in. Tagomi kills two of them with the Colt .44 from his collection, and as a man raised in a Buddhist culture he cannot recover from it. Soon the German consul brings a form for Frank Frink's extradition to Germany: Frink has been arrested for being Jewish. Tagomi refuses to sign, and Frink is released.
Juliana travels to Denver with Joe and realises from the I Ching's answers that he is an assassin sent to kill Abendsen. A newspaper reports that Joe Cinnadella was found in his hotel room with his throat cut by a razor blade, and that Juliana has vanished. Tagomi comes to Childan's shop to trade in the Colt; Childan shows him the new American jewellery from Frink's workshop: «This is my country's new life».
Juliana arrives at Abendsen's house in Cheyenne. Abendsen's wife Caroline admits the book was written with the I Ching: thousands of plot choices were put to the oracle. Juliana asks the oracle herself why it wrote «The Grasshopper». The answer is «Chung Fu — Inner Truth»: the book is true, Germany and Japan lost the war. Abendsen cannot face it, and Juliana walks out into the night.
If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.