Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Novel

When the Rain Stops

Ferdi Tayfur
Review by: Türkanə Əliyeva10 September 20261 min read
A heavy melodrama by famous Turkish arabesque singer Ferdi Tayfur, following a prisoner sent into exile whose fate becomes entangled with that of a poor family he meets on the train.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who enjoy heavy, tear-jerking Turkish melodrama (arabesque literature)
  • Anyone who wants poverty, exile, and family tragedy told in a vivid, colloquial voice
  • Readers curious about the social landscape of 1980s-2000s Turkey (rural-to-urban migration, political violence)
Not a Fit
  • Readers looking for a light, upbeat, or fast-paced story
  • Those sensitive to depictions of sexual violence (the novel contains a disturbing scene)
  • Readers who prefer spare, minimalist literary prose over dense, emotional rhetoric
How Readers Rate It
Pace 2.4/5 Slow
Emotional weight 4.2/5 High
Darkness 4.0/5 Heavy
35 voters
Two tragedies collide on a train: prisoner Veli and poor Emine
Covers roughly the first 76 pages (~28% of the book) — the train journey aboard the Toros Express, Veli's childhood memories, and the opening scenes of his new life in Istanbul; later events are not covered. For the spoiler, the airport scene and the final chapter were also read.

The novel opens at the Adana train station, where prisoner Veli Yüklü, escorted by gendarmes, is being exiled to another city. Sharing his compartment is a poor family: a dying old man, his daughter Emine, and young son Sinan. It emerges they are heading to Istanbul so the man can see a doctor — along the journey, the family's conversations reveal their poverty and the tension between father and daughter over Emine's cut-short education.

Watching the family, Veli recalls a tragedy from his own childhood in eastern Anatolia: two young "forest workers" who took shelter in a village turn out to be armed militants, and when soldiers raid the village, a woman's son is shot dead — she herself then endures a long court battle. This memory becomes intertwined with the history of Veli's own family and country.

Veli recalls that he too was a porter's son, walking miles each day just to reach school despite poverty. While in prison he began writing a screenplay — spending six years on a story called "Suçlu Melek" (Guilty Angel) that he never finished — and now sees the fates of his fellow passengers as material for "a novel not yet written."

As the train crosses the Taurus Mountains, small, humane moments (buying simit bread from a boy vendor, informal banter between the gendarme and the prisoner, the boy's playful mischief) soften the heavy atmosphere of the journey. Ferdi Tayfur's style is dense with metaphor and pathos-laden interior monologue — every small detail is charged with symbolic weight.

The third chapter shifts the action to Istanbul. Veli is released under an amnesty and moves in with his sister Asiye and her husband Nazım, whom he barely knows. At the same time, the reader learns of a traumatic event that befell Emine after her own move to Istanbul: an older woman named Billur, who seemed to take a caring interest in her, gets her drunk and attempts to assault her — Emine escapes, but is left deeply traumatized.

At this point the novel sets up two parallel threads: Veli's attempts to adjust to a new life in Istanbul (working as a house painter for his brother-in-law, chafing at being called "kaynço") and the aftermath of Emine's trauma. The chapter title names both threads together ("Lives Crossing in Istanbul: Veli, Emine, Asiye, Sinan"), signaling that their paths will fully converge later on.

Reading Experience
  • Chapters are long and dense, heavy on dialogue, but the interior monologues are pathos-laden and repetitive — a rhetoric reminiscent of arabesque song lyrics
  • The narrative voice mostly follows Veli, though it occasionally shifts into the thoughts of other characters, including Emine and even fellow train passengers
  • No translation exists (Turkish only), but the dialogue preserves an eastern Anatolian dialect throughout
Content Warning
Contains an undetailed but clearly depicted scene of sexual violence (an attempted assault after the victim is deliberately gotten drunk)Depicts an armed confrontation and the death of a childContains depictions of poverty and severe illness
If You Liked This
Madonna in a Fur CoatSabahattin Ali

Shares Turkish literature's classic melodramatic, fate-bound romance/tragedy tone

ElçibəyMir Yəhya Yusifli

A similarly heavy, fate-driven Anatolian/Caucasus-themed prose work on this site

Spoiler
How does the story of Veli and Emine end?
⚠️ The final chapters: the airport and the prison yard.

Emine has fallen into Çakal's network and is being used as a courier. At the airport Veli asks her to marry him, and she throws her arms around his neck: «Yes, yes, yes». As she passes through passport control, a sniper in a black minibus shoots her in the temple. Emine dies in Veli's arms without managing a word. Veli entrusts her little brother Sinan to his trusted friend Arto.

By the end Veli is back in prison. İmam, the only true friend he has found there, discovered his wife Nermin's affair with Sami and burned them both in a caravan. İmam is hanged in the prison yard; his last wish is to ask whether he will meet Nermin in the next world. Towards dawn the rain has stopped and the sky is clear. Veli watches from the window in tears while the prisoners wave handkerchiefs from theirs. The book's title comes from this final scene.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A dark, poetic novel of the eve of war, following a doctor who fled fascism into an undocumented, nameless existence in Paris — weaving love and revenge, exile and the sheer instinct to survive into the same sentence.
4.6 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Arch of Triumph

Arch of Triumph

Erich Maria Remarque · Classics
Reviews
Neuroanthropologist John S. Allen takes the evolution of the human brain beyond the simple story of «it got bigger, we got smarter», combining findings from fossils, brain anatomy, neuroimaging, genetics, diet, ageing and language. It is scholarly, serious and wide-ranging — the chapters on the «expensive tissue» hypothesis and the ageing brain are especially interesting; but its dense terminology and textbook tone make it heavy going for general readers.
3.9 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
The Lives of the Brain — Human Evolution and the Organ of Mind

The Lives of the Brain — Human Evolution and the Organ of Mind

John S. Allen · Non-fiction
Reviews
Jane Austen's last completed novel — mature, quiet and one of her saddest love stories. The story of Anne Elliot, who eight years earlier broke off her engagement to a penniless naval officer on the advice of a close friend, keeps Austen's irony while turning toward deeper themes of regret and second chances. Sir Walter's vanity, Mary's endless complaints and the noise of the Musgrove household are wonderfully drawn. This Turkish edition needs a separate warning, though: it is sold as “Love, Despite Everything” rather than “İkna”, the translation is muddled and heavy in places. The novel itself is a five-star book; this edition is weaker — choose another translation if you can.
4.5 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Persuasion

Persuasion

Jane Austen · Classics
Reviews
A bold book from the author of «Trauma and Recovery» about the fourth stage of healing: justice. Herman asks survivors of violence what they actually want, and the answer is not punishment but acknowledgment of the truth and repair of the harm. The idea is strong and the testimonies are moving, but almost every example comes from the US and from sexual violence, and the style at times slips into an academic, manifesto-like tone.
4.3 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
Truth and Repair

Truth and Repair

Judith L. Herman · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text