Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Atatürk: The Rebirth of a Nation

In English: Atatürk: The Rebirth of a Nation
Lord Kinross
Review by: Türkanə Əliyeva06 October 20261 min read
One of the best-known English-language biographies of Atatürk. The British journalist and historian Lord Kinross drew on the presidential archive at Çankaya, the papers of British diplomats and interviews with dozens of people who knew Atatürk. The book tells both the great military and political story and the man's character vividly: his pride, impatience, wit and weaknesses. But it was written in 1964, does not cover later research, and the author's admiration shows in places.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers looking for a detailed, readable introduction to the founding of the Republic of Turkey
  • Those who want to see a great figure's political and private life in one book
  • Anyone interested in the late Ottoman period, the Balkans and the First World War
Not a Fit
  • Readers seeking recent archival research and historiographical debate
  • Those who want a short biography: the book runs to more than 500 pages
  • Anyone expecting either a purely critical or a purely laudatory text: the author sits in between
How Readers Rate It
Readability 3.9/5 Easy
Historical detail 4.2/5 A lot
Objectivity 2.9/5 Average
40 voters
Preface and chapter one «Birth of a Macedonian»
Read: the acknowledgements, the preface, chapter one «Birth of a Macedonian» in full and the first pages of chapter two «An Officer's Education» (pp. 9–29 of the Turkish edition). About 5% of the book. The remaining chapters were not read and are described only from the table of contents.

The acknowledgements show how the book was made. Kinross was admitted to the presidential archive at Çankaya, helped by Professor Enver Ziya Karal of Ankara University, and allowed to use the papers of Sir Horace Rumbold, British ambassador in Istanbul. He also spoke with dozens of people who had known Atatürk personally, such as Kazım Özalp and Fuat Köprülü. This gives the book a rare liveliness: events are built not only from documents but also from witnesses' memories.

The preface is a portrait in itself. Atatürk is described as someone who «did not fit the usual Turkish type»: fair, high-cheekboned, with steel-blue eyes. He took care over his clothes, talked with friends late into the night, and sometimes took decisions about running the country at the dinner table. The author sees a politician who «reached liberal ends by illiberal means», who read people unerringly and knew when to persuade and when to intimidate. His quip about İsmet İnönü is here too: «Fifty foxes chase each other in his belly, but none ever catches another's tail».

Chapter one takes the reader to late nineteenth-century Macedonia, where Muslims, Christians and Jews, Turks, Greeks, Slavs, Vlachs and Albanians lived side by side. Mustafa, born in Salonica in 1881, was the son of Ali Rıza Efendi, a customs official who went into the timber trade, and Zübeyde Hanım, a devout woman who wanted her son to become a hafız. The parents' quarrel ends in a comic compromise: the boy is sent with ceremony to the neighbourhood religious school, then quietly moved to the modern Şemsi Efendi school. At the religious school little Mustafa refuses to write cross-legged on the floor and tells the teacher, «Yes, I am defying you», and the whole class backs him.

The most moving pages are the years of poverty. The father loses his money in the salt trade, falls ill and dies. The mother takes the children to her brother's farm near Salonica. Mustafa and his sister Makbule chase crows away from the beans and roast chestnuts by the fire on winter nights. The author writes that perhaps for the first time Mustafa felt a love of land and nature, but soon grew bored because he wanted to learn. His envy of a neighbour's boy strutting in a military-school uniform would decide his future.

The second half of the chapter moves to the Monastir military high school. Here the teenage Mustafa Kemal sees Greek, Bulgarian and Serbian bands trying to tear Rumelia apart. In the 1897 war he tries to run off to the front as a volunteer with a friend but is sent back. The poet Ömer Naci introduces him to literature, and Ali Fethi to French and to philosophers such as Rousseau, Voltaire and Montesquieu. The author does not hide the Salonica taverns, the dance lessons or the reply «I am going to be someone important». The chapter ends with his admission to the War College in Istanbul in 1899.

The first pages of chapter two describe turn-of-the-century Istanbul as two separate cities: north of the Golden Horn the bright, Europeanised Pera of the Christians, to the south the crumbling old city of the Muslims. Thanks to the capitulations all the wealth is in foreign hands, and Turks feel like captives in their own country. The young Mustafa Kemal is lonely at first, then befriends Ali Fuat and finds a father's affection in the home of Fuat's father, İsmail Fazıl Pasha. Under Abdülhamid's regime of spies he reads banned French books and Namık Kemal secretly at night.

Reading Experience
  • Prose that flows like a novel, blending documents with witnesses' memories
  • A structure that runs the great historical backdrop (the Ottoman collapse) alongside the personal story
  • A portrait that shows its hero's weaknesses but remains broadly sympathetic
  • A chapter layout that clearly marks the major turning points
Content Warning
War, ethnic conflict and political violence are describedWritten in 1964: some judgements are disputed by later researchAlcohol and private relationships are discussed openlyA book about a real political figure: readers may judge it very differently
If You Liked This
Tek AdamŞevket Süreyya Aydemir

The classic three-volume Turkish biography of Atatürk

Atatürk: An Intellectual BiographyM. Şükrü Hanioğlu

Examines Atatürk's world of ideas with current historiography

The Fall of the OttomansEugene Rogan

Opens up the historical backdrop of the book's first part in more depth

Spoiler
How does Mustafa get into military school, and who gives him the name «Kemal»?
⚠️ The middle of chapter one: the Salonica military school.

Zübeyde Hanım does not want her son to be a soldier: she hopes he will follow the Prophet's path or become a merchant, and she fears war and exile. Mustafa secretly gets help from the neighbour boy Ahmet's father, a major, sits the military school's entrance exam without telling his mother, and passes. When her signature is needed, he reminds her that his father hung a sword over his cradle when he was born: «I was born a soldier, and I will die a soldier». What finally decides her is a dream: she sees her son sitting on a golden tray at the top of a minaret, and a voice says that if she lets him go, he will always stay this high.

At school Mustafa is far ahead of his classmates in mathematics. His mathematics teacher, also named Mustafa, follows an old Turkish custom and gives him a second name to tell them apart: «Kemal», meaning «perfection». The name will stay with him until his death. Meanwhile his mother remarries a wealthy widower, Ragıp Efendi. Mustafa is jealous at first but comes to get along with him, and from an older stepbrother who is an officer he receives advice on honour and a knife to defend himself.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
The core book of the 'Montignac Method', which sold millions of copies in the 1980s and 1990s: it rejects calorie counting, attributes weight gain mainly to insulin spikes caused by 'bad carbohydrates', and proposes a two-phase diet built on the glycaemic index. Some of its ideas — the glycaemic index itself, avoiding sugar and white flour, favouring fibre — later found scientific support. But categorical claims such as 'counting calories is nonsense' and 'low-calorie diets make you fat' contradict what science knows about energy balance, and allowing wine and beer with every meal even during the weight-loss phase is debatable.
2.7 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Eat Yourself Slim… and Stay Slim!

Eat Yourself Slim… and Stay Slim!

Michel Montignac · Non-fiction
Reviews
Written in the aftermath of a personal crisis (a mother's death and the collapse of a marriage) and famously called "the book I hate most" by Christie, this Poirot novel nonetheless delivers every ingredient of the classic "murder aboard a train" formula: a mysterious jewel, a thief in disguise, an unexpected killer.
3.9 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
The Mystery of the Blue Train

The Mystery of the Blue Train

Agatha Christie · Classics
Reviews
A practical, warm parenting guide that builds children's organising habits around four «brain types» — Penguin, Dog, Horse and Lion — and teaches parents to understand a «messy» child's natural style rather than blame it, though its scientific basis is debatable.
3.4 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Every Child Has a Thinking Style

Every Child Has a Thinking Style

Lanna Nakone · Non-fiction
Reviews
From Goldsmiths, University of London economist William Davies, a sharp critical work of economic sociology arguing that "the science of happiness" — positive psychology, neuroscience, the wellbeing industry — has in fact become a tool of social control and profit for corporations and governments.
4.3 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
The Happiness Industry

The Happiness Industry

William Davies · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text