Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Far Eastern Civilisations — China, Japan, Korea

Douglas Baehr
Review by: İdris Muxtarzadə28 September 20261 min read
An overview that tries to fit all of Chinese history from the Xia to the Qing dynasty, plus Japan and Korea, into a pocket book: the final chapter comparing the three peoples' myths is interesting, but the Japan section is copied word for word from the same publisher's «Shinto» volume, some claims of «Turkic origins» lack any scholarly basis, and the vast subject stays superficial.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who want a quick grasp of the sequence of Chinese dynasties
  • Anyone curious about Far Eastern mythology — Nüwa, Fuxi, Huangdi, Amaterasu
  • School and university students as a first overview
  • Readers of the series' other «Civilisations» volumes
Not a Fit
  • Readers of the series' «Shinto» volume expecting new material
  • Those looking for academic precision and source criticism
  • Anyone expecting Japan and Korea to get as much space as China
How Readers Rate It
Scope 3.9/5 Broad
Accuracy 2.6/5 Average
Readability 3.3/5 Average
40 voters
Chapter 16 — «Chinese, Japanese and Korean Mythologies Examined through Shared Legends»
The book's final, sixteenth chapter (approx. pp. 155–168, about 10% of the book) was read and analysed. The chapters on Chinese dynasties and on the history of Japan and Korea are described only in general terms.

The chapter opens with a good theoretical introduction: myths reflect a society's culture in its simplest form, and in the Far East it is impossible to draw a firm line between historical figures and legendary heroes. The author lists «universal patterns» that recur in world mythologies: the entrance to the underworld being a cave, a rainbow bridge linking heaven and earth, divine places on high mountain tops, and anyone who eats the food of the underworld being unable to return. Lévi-Strauss's «evil father-in-law» myth — the father who puts the hero through deadly trials and the daughter who sides with her husband against him — is given as an intriguing parallel between Japan and the Americas.

The section on Chinese mythology is the fullest. It introduces the «Five Legendary Emperors» — the Yellow Emperor Huangdi, ancestor of the Chinese; Zhuanxu, who cut the link between heaven and earth; Yao, who devised the calendar; Shun, embodiment of virtue; and Yu the Great, who tamed the flood. It describes the divine order ruling the four directions and four seasons from Huangdi's throne on Mount Kunlun; the cosmic egg split into Yin and Yang and the giant Pangu; the dragon symbolising heaven and the tiger symbolising earth; and Xiwangmu, the Queen Mother of the West, who guards the peach of immortality. The most striking myth is Nüwa's creation of humans: the rich come from figurines she carefully shaped from river clay, and ordinary people from drops of mud flung from a vine.

The section on ancestor worship shows well the thread linking the three countries: at China's Zhongyuan, Japan's Obon and Korea's Baekjung festivals, ancestral spirits are believed to return home. The head of the family's right and duty to pray to the ancestors at the household shrine survives to this day. This is the truly «comparative» part of the chapter and gives readers a key to understanding East Asia's religious and cultural unity.

But this section also contains problematic claims. The book writes that the Zhou dynasty is «thought to have been originally Turkic» and that ancestor worship is «thought to derive from the Turks' belief in Gök Tengri» — each time noting there is «no conclusive evidence», yet it is unclear why these hypotheses are included at all. Such claims of origin are not accepted in serious scholarship, and their presence in a pocket encyclopaedia may mislead readers.

The most serious problem is in the Japan section. The paragraphs beginning «Shinto means the way of the gods…», covering the Kojiki, the Nihongi, the concept of kami and the three-layered universe, are word for word identical to the introduction of the same publisher's «Shinto», published under the name Robby Silver. This shows that the series' «author» names should be treated with caution and that the texts are copied from a common source. Readers of both books will read this section twice.

Even so, by comparing Chinese myths with Greek mythology the chapter explains an important difference well: in China there is no firm line between gods and humans, and people such as General Guan Yu were later deified. It is a useful map for a first look at Far Eastern myths, but the rest of the book — especially its brief summaries of the dynasties — should be supplemented with a more serious history.

Reading Experience
  • Chronological chapters by Chinese dynasty
  • Quotations from mythological texts and scholars (Lévi-Strauss, Birrell)
  • Colour illustrations and short marginal notes
  • Bibliography and the translator's sources at the end
Content Warning
The Japan section is copied word for word from the series' «Shinto» volumeSome claims of origin lack a scholarly basis
If You Liked This
Shinto — Spirits of the AncestorsRobby Silver

From the same publisher, more detailed on Japanese mythology and Shinto — reviewed on our site

Mesopotamian Civilisations — Sumer, Akkad, Assyria, BabylonDouglas Baehr

From the same series, on another great ancient civilisation — reviewed on our site

Buddhism — A Journey to NirvanaRobby Silver

On Buddhism, which shaped the religious life of the Far East — reviewed on our site

Spoiler
How does this part end?
⚠️ Chinese myths and Guan Yu

The chapter compares Chinese myths with Greek mythology and explains an important difference — that in China there is no boundary between gods and humans, and that people such as General Guan Yu were later deified.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A long, episodic, sexually explicit American novel in which a Jewish Brooklyn youth rises from erotic pulp stories to Hollywood screenwriting and world-famous authorship. Its strongest quality is the lively portrait of 1940s Brooklyn, Hollywood and Europe and of the publishing-and-film market. Its weaknesses are the scattered plot, repeated sex scenes, drugs, a coarse attitude to women and a hero who shows almost no inner development.
3.0 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
Şöhretin Yasası

Şöhretin Yasası

Harold Robbins · Novel
Reviews
In an unnamed city, street fighting, raids and a «state of emergency» have gone on for years, and everyone is waiting for the «secret order» that will bring salvation. Melih Cevdet Anday's second novel is a dark allegory that recalls Kafka and Beckett yet grows entirely out of Turkish reality: a book about bureaucracy, political empty talk and waiting turned into an ideology. It is very clever, at times funny and frightening. Its weakness: the allegory sometimes repeats itself and long dialogues weigh the novel down.
4.0 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Gizli Emir (The Secret Order)

Gizli Emir (The Secret Order)

Melih Cevdet Anday · Novel
Reviews
A love-and-family novel set in 1953 Philadelphia: Jory Ryan, on the eve of divorce, faces the love she left behind and a wounded past. Its strongest side is the warm, humorous tone, the vivid depiction of the family struggle and the sharpness of Justine Landers. Its weak side is the likelihood of repeated scenes and very easily resolved turns.
3.4 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Serendipity

Serendipity

Fern Michaels · Novel
Reviews
The most authoritative, repeatedly revised general introduction to Maya civilization — written from archaeologist Michael D. Coe's more than sixty years of scholarship, and accessible to both specialists and general readers.
4.4 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
The Maya

The Maya

Michael D. Coe · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text