Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Novel

The Devil’s Star

Jo Nesbø
Review by: Rafel Əlizadə24 September 20261 min read
Harry Hole's fifth outing: a drink-sodden detective on the brink of dismissal tracks, through a stifling Oslo summer, a killer who leaves behind a severed finger and a red diamond under the eyelid — one of the darkest and most skilfully built entries in the series.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who love the dark, psychologically layered atmosphere of Scandinavian noir
  • Harry Hole fans waiting for the «Prince» storyline to pay off
  • Anyone looking for crime fiction that treats addiction and self-destruction seriously
  • Crime readers who enjoy forensic detail — powder burns, blood clotting, crime-scene reasoning
Not a Fit
  • Readers who want to start the series here — the Ellen Gjelten and Waaler threads feel incomplete without the earlier books
  • Those sensitive to explicit depictions of murder
  • Anyone after a quick, light one-sitting mystery — the opening chapters are slow and dense
How Readers Rate It
Tension 4.1/5 Tense
Darkness of tone 4.5/5 Bleak
Readability 3.8/5 Flowing
44 voters
Part One and the start of Part Two — the Camilla Loen murder
Covers the novel from the opening through the chapter «Wednesday. Missing» (roughly the first 60 pages, ~15% of the book): the water-drip prologue, the discovery of Camilla Loen's body, Harry's dismissal and the disappearance of a second woman. The killer's identity and the course of the investigation are not revealed here.

Nesbø opens with an unusual shot: a leak seeping through the floorboards, plaster and old newspaper pages of an 1898 building until it drips into a pot on the stove below. This long, almost cinematic «journey of the water» tells the house's century-old history — a legend of a woman walled up alive, a mason who fell from the scaffolding — while setting up an unexpected detail: clots of blood in boiling water that look like bits of egg. It is a masterful opening, though it tests an impatient reader.

When the police story begins, Nesbø exploits the summer emptiness of the station: half the department is on holiday, and Chief Inspector Bjarne Møller, running his finger down the duty roster, has no choice but to send two sworn enemies to the same scene. That sets up the book's central tension: the murder inquiry is really the backdrop for a hidden war between two detectives. Tom Waaler is flawless, composed and in control; Harry arrives sweaty, drunk and with a scab on his nose.

Crime-scene writing is Nesbø's strength. Drunk as he is, Harry works with Beate Lønn to read the distance and angle of the shot from the powder burns around the wound, and deduces from the blood loss that the finger was cut off while the victim was still alive. These scenes are cold, precise and convincing; rather than scattering clues, the author shows how a detective's mind actually works.

The real weight of the novel, though, is Harry himself. His relationship with Rakel has collapsed, his obsession with the Ellen Gjelten case has tipped into paranoia, his only witness has recanted, and the head of Kripos has threatened him with «the Hole–Waaler case». Nesbø never romanticises alcoholism: the squalid flat, the vomiting, the blackouts, a brain that automatically remembers bar opening hours — all rendered bare and uncomfortable. Møller's line «Rakel and the job were all you had» is the emotional centre of these chapters.

Short italicised monologues — the killer's own voice — add a cold second layer. Beginning with «water for the thirsty», these passages let the reader sense the killer watching Harry and pose early the question of who is hunting whom. Side threads such as the chapter with Aftenposten crime reporter Roger Gjendem enrich the picture with the city's summer lethargy, a sensation-hungry press, and quiet social detail like a brother lost to heroin.

The Turkish translation reads smoothly overall, but typesetting and proofreading slips (Møller printed as «M0İler», assorted letter errors) may bother an attentive reader. Even so, the first 15% offers one of the strongest openings in the series — both as a crime novel and as a portrait of a man on the verge of collapse.

Reading Experience
  • A cinematic prologue that follows water dripping through the history of a building
  • Chapters titled by day and keyword («Friday. Egg», «Friday. Water») create a steady rhythm
  • The killer's brief italic interior monologues open a second point of view
  • Forensic details are precise and plausible; the detective's reasoning is shown step by step
Content Warning
Explicit depiction of murder and mutilation, bloody scenesSevere alcoholism, self-destruction and a depressive moodA gruesome legend of a woman walled up alive; references to domestic violence
If You Liked This
The RedbreastJo Nesbø

The third Harry Hole novel, which launches the Ellen Gjelten and «Prince» storyline — reviewed on our site

The Girl with the Dragon TattooStieg Larsson

The same Scandinavian darkness, violence against women and a damaged investigator

Spoiler
What happens in the opening chapters?
⚠️ Key events from the first 15% of the novel.

The five-pointed red diamond found under Camilla Loen's eyelid — the «devil's star» — is the killer's signature. The weapon, a Glock 23 with its serial number filed off, turns up in the bin under the sink, and Beate notes it matches the type of guns recently seized in Oslo, steering the reader back toward the «Prince» arms-smuggling ring. Harry keeps insisting it is not his case.

Meanwhile the backstory unfolds: Harry's only witness, Roy Kvinsvik, retracted at the last moment, the head of Kripos threatened him, and Møller has signed his dismissal — it only awaits the chief's signature when he returns from holiday. In this three-week limbo Harry shows up at work again. At the end of the section a strange man named Wilhelm Barli reports that his wife Lisbeth went to the corner shop two hours ago and never came back — the shadow of a second victim.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text