Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Novel

The Violets of March

Sarah Jio
Review by: Aytən Həsənova25 September 20261 min read
A warm, readable and mysterious novel that moves between two timelines through a 1943 diary found by a divorced writer on an island: the atmosphere and family secret are very appealing, though some characters and the romantic thread feel somewhat formulaic.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Fans of dual-timeline family-secret novels
  • Readers looking for seaside, small-island atmosphere and a comforting read
  • Readers of romantic drama in the vein of Kate Morton or Nicholas Sparks
  • Those wanting a light, hopeful story about divorce and starting over
Not a Fit
  • Readers expecting complex prose and deep psychological analysis
  • Those tired of romance clichés (handsome neighbour, old flame)
  • Anyone after a fast, tense plot — the pace is gentle
How Readers Rate It
Atmosphere 4.2/5 Very strong
Originality 3.0/5 Average
Readability 4.4/5 Flowing
41 voters
The first four chapters — from New York to Bainbridge Island
The first four chapters of the novel (about 90 pages, ~27% of the book) were read: Emily's divorce, her arrival on the island, meeting Henry and Jack, finding the diary, and running into an old flame at the market. The diary's central secret, Esther's identity and the ending are not revealed in this review.

The novel opens with a bittersweet scene: as Emily tapes up the last box, Joel nearly takes her beloved book with him; then he locks the door from outside as he leaves — 'he still cares about my safety'. Emily remembers the end of her marriage by the smell of burnt hot-sauce omelette; small, concrete details like this are Jio's strength. As she signs the divorce papers in a restaurant, her best friend Annabelle explains a funny theory based on her doctoral research: the lifespan of a marriage is determined by the husband's name. 'Joel — seven years, two weeks.' This humour nicely balances the novel's melancholy tone.

Emily's creative block is convincing too: her first novel, written eight years ago, was a bestseller and was filmed, but ever since she has stared at a blank screen every morning. Annabelle urges her to write about something she genuinely cares about, and Emily thinks of her mother's aunt Bee. A childhood memory — a photo hung high in the hallway of young Bee on a beach while another woman whispers in her ear — and a painting Bee once gave her become the key to the plot: the woman in the painting is Bee, but the curly, dark-haired man holding her hand is not Uncle Bill.

The arrival on the island shows Jio's gift for description: the ferry, the salty smell of Puget Sound, the shingled houses along the shore, Bee's green 1963 Volkswagen driven at speed without a working seatbelt. Eighty-five, still dressing as if she were in her twenties, pouring wine into a coffee cup and calling it 'my medicine', Bee is the novel's liveliest character. The warm welcome and the gin sipped in silence by the fire give the book a comfortable, cosy rhythm.

On the beach Emily meets the neighbour Henry: the island's stone-skipping 'champion' (his record is fourteen), an old man who still keeps on his mantelpiece a photo of the fiancée he failed to marry sixty years ago. At his house the neighbour Jack appears — tall, a little shy, walking the beach with his dog Russ — and invites Emily to dinner on Saturday. But Bee, having watched them from the window, issues a brief warning: 'Be careful. Especially with Jack.' She won't say why. It neatly establishes the novel's 'everyone on this island has a secret' motif.

In the fourth chapter, in the market's wine cellar, Emily runs into her teenage love Greg, who also asks her out to dinner. Here the novel's weakness shows: within a few chapters two handsome single men cross the heroine's path, and the love triangle falls into a very familiar pattern. Even so, Emily's inner monologue — the embarrassment of meeting an old flame in rubber boots and a shabby wool sweater — is honest and funny.

The real engine of the novel, though, is the diary. The first page of the red velvet notebook found in the pink guest room reads 'draft book', and then, in beautiful handwriting, 'The Story of What Happened on a Small Island in 1943'. A married woman — Esther — writes about meeting a man called Elliot and how her husband Bobby never held her like that. These passages are the most gripping part of the book and compel the reader, like Emily, to keep going 'just one more page'. The Turkish translation reads smoothly.

Reading Experience
  • Two timelines: March 2005 and a diary from 1943
  • First-person narration with a candid, humorous inner monologue
  • Strong sense of place: the island, the beach, the old house
  • Each chapter ends on a small secret or question
Content Warning
The theme of an extramarital affairA few mildly erotic memory scenesAlcohol is frequently depicted
If You Liked This
Broken CountryClare Leslie Hall

Another novel moving between past and present, built on an old love and a family secret — reviewed on our site

The Midnight LibraryMatt Haig

A warm, hopeful novel about a woman at a dead end searching for a second chance — reviewed on our site

Spoiler
What happens in the opening chapters?
⚠️ Key events from the first ~27% of the novel.

Emily signs the divorce papers on 28 February 2005 and, back home, finds Joel's wedding invitation with his new girlfriend Stephanie. Bee's postcard reads: 'When the time is right, the island calls back those who belong here... Come home.' Emily arrives on the island on the first of March; on the phone Bee had said 'there is something important I need to talk to you about', but she doesn't reveal it yet.

Emily realises that the man in the painting is not Uncle Bill, notices Henry avoiding the subject of the former fiancée in the photo on his mantelpiece, and senses Bee's open coldness towards Jack. In the diary, Esther kisses Elliot on a cold March night in 1943 and writes that the chain of events that began then would change her life and the lives of those around her forever. The portion covered by this review ends as Bee, at the market, is about to introduce Emily to a woman of her own age with jet-black eyes.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A collection of the short newspaper columns the Turkish journalist Candaş Tolga Işık wrote for «Posta» between 2009 and 2013: each piece is a sharp, ironic and direct reaction to the news (crimes, earthquake and flood, education, politics, the army and the courts). In the first columns read, the strongest side is a short-paragraphed, colloquial and effective style; the weakest is that read outside their historical context the pieces often come across as newspaper jargon and partisan commentary, and some figures are given without sources. For those interested in the style and agenda of the Turkish press in the 2010s.
3.2 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
The Land of Imported Fears

The Land of Imported Fears

Candaş Tolga Işık · Non-fiction
Reviews
A short but substantive introduction to Judaism written by Turkish theologian Fuat Aydın from an outside, academic history-of-religions perspective — aimed at the non-specialist reader, yet grounded in real sources.
4.3 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Judaism: History, Belief, Worship, Culture

Judaism: History, Belief, Worship, Culture

Fuat Aydın · Non-fiction
Reviews
A short guide to depression drawing mostly on clinical literature: symptoms, thinking errors, how families should approach the patient and treatment options are explained clearly, but the text relies on outdated information (DSM-IV, WHO projections «for 2020» still in the future tense), contains some wrong or misleading sentences, and its final chapter is a list of nursing diagnoses rather than case studies.
3.0 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Depression — A Potential Affliction, Suppressing Emotions

Depression — A Potential Affliction, Suppressing Emotions

Angela Dainty · Non-fiction
Reviews
A practical guide to learning and exam stress that has been a standard reference for Turkish cram schools and school counsellors for over thirty years. Its strength is concrete method: how to start studying, plan time, strengthen memory, listen actively, read using an SQ3R-based technique and reduce exam anxiety. But the book was first written in 1989 and it shows: some information is outdated, much is tied to Turkey's exam system, and sections such as «careers of the future» have not aged well.
3.6 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Superior Success in Learning and Exams

Superior Success in Learning and Exams

Acar Baltaş · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text