Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Mesopotamian Civilisations — Sumer, Akkad, Assyria, Babylon

Douglas Baehr
Review by: Türkanə Əliyeva28 September 20261 min read
An illustrated pocket history that tours the civilisations between the two rivers in chronological order, from Sumer to Neo-Babylon: the generous space given to the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Flood text makes it interesting, but the text feels patched together from different sources, with contradictory information within the same chapter and some factual errors.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers wanting a short, illustrated introduction to ancient Near Eastern history
  • Anyone curious about the Epic of Gilgamesh and the origins of the Flood myth
  • School and university students as a first overview
  • Readers of the series' other «Civilisations» volumes
Not a Fit
  • Those expecting academic accuracy and references
  • Readers who want a coherent history written in a single authorial voice
  • Anyone who already knows the basics of Mesopotamia — they may find nothing new
How Readers Rate It
Scope 3.7/5 Broad
Accuracy 2.6/5 Average
Readability 3.4/5 Average
40 voters
Chapter 4 — «The Epic of Gilgamesh»
The book's fourth chapter (pp. 35–44, about 6% of the book) was read and analysed. The other chapters on the Sumerians, cuneiform, Akkad, Assyria, Babylon and the Kassites are described only in general terms.

The chapter presents the Epic of Gilgamesh as history's first written epic: the quest for immortality of a king believed to have ruled Uruk in the 28th century BC. The book explains that the epic was written down about a thousand years after the king, that twelve clay tablets have been found, and that they are incomplete. It lists the tablets from the library of the Assyrian king Ashurbanipal at Nineveh and the finds at Nippur, Sultantepe and Boğazköy. The most interesting detail is the tablet acquired from a smuggler in Iraq in 2011 and given to the Sulaymaniyah Museum: in Andrew George's words, its new lines depict the Cedar Forest as a lively place full of noisy birds and screeching monkeys.

The plot is then retold: the wild Enkidu, created as a rival to Gilgamesh who oppresses his people; their fight and friendship; the rejection of the love goddess Ishtar's marriage proposal; the killing of the Bull of Heaven; the gods condemning Enkidu to death; Gilgamesh's lament and his quest for immortality. The wise Utnapishtim who survived the Flood, the plant of immortality brought up from the sea bed and its loss to a snake — the saddest moment of the epic — are told briefly but effectively. The book compares the «plant of immortality» motif to the Turkish-Islamic legend of Luqman the physician.

The fullest part of the chapter is the section «The Epic of Gilgamesh and the Flood». It opens with George Smith announcing in 1872 that he had found the Flood story among the Assyrian tablets in the British Museum, then quotes long passages from the epic: the god Ea commanding Utnapishtim of Shuruppak to tear down his house and build a ship; the ship's dimensions, six decks and coat of pitch; the animals slaughtered for the workers and wine flowing like a river; family and animals taken aboard; the storm raging for six days and seven nights; and the ship coming to rest on Mount Nisir. These are the book's best pages and help explain how the Flood myth passed into the scriptures of three major religions.

But the chapter's weaknesses will not escape a careful reader. Within the same chapter Enkidu is first said to have been sent by the sky god Anu to kill Gilgamesh, and a few pages later to have been created by the goddess Aruru in answer to the prayers of Uruk's women — the text feels compiled from two different sources. In one place Utnapishtim himself is said to bring the plant up from the sea bed, whereas in the epic it is Gilgamesh who dives for it. The claim that the Flood was started by Ishtar and Bel also does not match the traditional reading.

Still, the chapter also addresses the question of the historical Gilgamesh: the Sumerian King List names him as the fifth king of Uruk after the Flood, reigning for 126 years; the list is thought to date from the Third Dynasty of Ur; a Sumerian tablet from Me-Turan describes the people of Uruk diverting the Euphrates to bury their king in the riverbed; and a structure found in 2003 has been claimed to be that tomb. Marginal boxes give short notes on Enkidu and the sun god Utu-Shamash.

Overall, the Gilgamesh chapter is the most interesting and readable part of the book: it gives a first-time reader a good sense of the plot, the historical context and the Flood text. But unsourced information, internal contradictions and editing errors make it only a first source of information. For anyone who wants to read the epic itself, the best next step after this chapter is a full translation.

Reading Experience
  • A chronological chapter structure
  • Colour illustrations and short notes in marginal boxes
  • Long direct quotations from the Epic of Gilgamesh
  • Bibliography and the translator's sources at the end
Content Warning
Contains descriptions of war, death and natural disasterContradictory information and factual errors within the text
If You Liked This
Prehistoric Mesopotamia: New Approaches, New Interpretations, and New ChronologyHalil Tekin

Covers Mesopotamia before writing at an academic level — reviewed on our site

A History of the Ancient WorldGeorge Stephen Goodspeed

Places Mesopotamia in the wider context of Egypt, Greece and Rome — reviewed on our site

Egypt and the EgyptiansDouglas J. Brewer and Emily Teeter

On the other great river civilisation that developed alongside Mesopotamia — reviewed on our site

Spoiler
How does this part end?
⚠️ The historical Gilgamesh: king of Uruk

The chapter also touches on the question of the historical Gilgamesh: the Sumerian King List says he ruled for 126 years as the fifth king of Uruk after the Flood, the Me-Turan tablet describes the people of Uruk diverting the Euphrates and burying the king in the riverbed, and the claim that a structure found in 2003 may be this tomb is noted.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A thematic introduction to large-scale world history from Kevin Reilly, founding president of the World History Association — the book opens with the Big Bang itself, races through cosmic and geological history up to the emergence of the human species, then gradually shifts into the great turning points of cultural history. A rare book that pairs academic rigor with genuinely accessible storytelling.
4.5 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
The Human Journey: A Concise Introduction to World History

The Human Journey: A Concise Introduction to World History

Kevin Reilly · Non-fiction
Reviews
Emotional Intelligence author Daniel Goleman and neuroscientist Richard Davidson strip meditation science of its marketing hype and examine what it actually shows — a rare book that both makes the case for meditation and sharply criticizes the exaggerated claims made about it.
4.0 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Altered Traits

Altered Traits

Daniel Goleman, Richard J. Davidson · Non-fiction
Reviews
A bestseller-style spy-and-adventure novel that combines 1970s Middle Eastern oil politics, Palestinian armed groups, drug smuggling and the collapse of a wealthy Arab family. Its strongest points are the lively backdrop of the period's events (the 1973 war, the oil embargo) and a tense chase thread. Its weaknesses are cliché characters, an excess of sex scenes, Arab and Jewish stereotypes and women turned into objects of violence.
3.2 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Fedai

Fedai

Harold Robbins · Novel
Reviews
A popular book that explains everyday habits (drinking water from the bottle, listening at doors, twisting the wedding ring, chewing matchsticks) through childhood memories and the subconscious, and then moves on to numbers, colours, palm and face lines, shyness and stress. In the part read, the strongest side is the short everyday scenes everyone recognises and the fluent language. The weakest side is that almost every explanation rests on an unproven formula, «your habit comes from such-and-such a childhood lack», that the «stories» about poets sound invented, and that number, colour and palm fortune-telling is presented as science. It is read for entertainment, not for self-knowledge or treatment.
2.4 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
The Person Inside Us

The Person Inside Us

Erdoğan Alkan · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text