Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

The Elements of Shamanism

Nevill Drury
Review by: Türkanə Əliyeva28 September 20261 min read
A compact introduction mapping shamanism from Siberia to the Amazon, grounded in Eliade and anthropological research: it explains shamanic cosmology, helping spirits and rituals clearly with examples from specific peoples, but some comparisons (Kabbalah, modern Western magic) pull it off course, and the 1996 Turkish translation is riddled with errors.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers wanting a short but anthropologically grounded introduction to shamanism
  • Those interested in the ancient beliefs of Turkic and Mongolic peoples
  • Anyone curious about mythology, the history of religions and «world tree» motifs
  • Readers who want a gentle start before tackling Mircea Eliade's heavy classic
Not a Fit
  • Those seeking up-to-date anthropology — the book dates from 1989
  • Readers expecting a high-quality Turkish translation
  • Anyone wanting to see shamanism only in a Turkic cultural context
How Readers Rate It
Scope 3.9/5 Broad
Scientific basis 3.4/5 Average
Translation quality 2.5/5 Average
40 voters
Chapter 3 — «Shamanic Cosmologies»
The book's third chapter (pp. 53–66 of the Turkish edition, about 8% of the book) was read and analysed. The chapters on animism, the geography of shamanism, ritual, sacred plants, shamans' own accounts and shamanism in the West are described only in general terms.

The chapter opens with a simple but powerful observation: myths, culture heroes and gods differ everywhere, yet once cultural variation is set aside, shamanic societies share a remarkably similar picture of how the universe is structured. Drury draws here on Mircea Eliade's «Shamanism: Archaic Techniques of Ecstasy», first published in Paris in 1951: the shaman's universe has three levels — an upper world, the middle world where humans live, and an underworld. They are linked by an «Axis Mundi» — the world axis, world tree or tree of life — along which the shaman travels from one level to another.

The most interesting part of the chapter shows how different peoples express the same idea through different images. Turkic-Tatar peoples see the sky as a tent with holes through which starlight shines; the Yakuts call the stars «windows of the world». The Pole Star is the «Nail of the Sky» for the Samoyeds, the «Golden Pillar» for Mongols and Buryats, the «Iron Pillar» for the Kyrgyz. Where there is no axis, its place is taken by cosmic mountains, ziggurats, bridges, ladders, rainbows or, as among the Evenks, a mighty river joining the three worlds. For readers from Turkic-speaking cultures this short list casts familiar motifs — the «world tree», the «sky tent» — in a new light.

The section on the world tree ranges widely: the Yakuts' eight-branched tree rising from «the golden core of the earth» to the sky; the Goldi and Dolgans, who believe the souls of unborn children sit like birds in its branches; Yggdrasil in Norse mythology, with its roots in Hel and trunk in Midgard; the Ottoman Turks' tree of a million leaves, each bearing a person's fate; the Dayaks' seven-branched tree carrying the dead to the sky. Drury also brings in the Kabbalistic «Tree of Life» of Jewish mysticism — intriguing, but its link to shamanic cosmology feels somewhat forced.

At the heart of the chapter is «Evenk Cosmology — A Special Case». For the Evenks the upper world is «ugu buga», the middle world «dulugu buga» and the lower world «khergu-ergu buga», all three joined by the mythical «Clan River». In the upper world live the creator god Amaka, Eksheri, master of animals, the thunder god Agdy, and old Dylacha, who stores heat in a leather bag and spreads it over the earth in spring. The lower world is the world turned upside down: the dead live there, along with disease spirits and the «Clan Mistress» who watches over taboos. The myth of the celestial elk Kheglen stealing the sun and the hero shaman Main shooting it with an arrow to bring the sun back is the chapter's most memorable page.

The section «Guiding Spirits» then divides the shaman's helpers into two groups: «familiar» spirits under the shaman's control and more independent guardian spirits. It describes Siberian shamans' bonds with animals such as bears, wolves and eagles, the Yakuts regarding bulls, eagles and bears as the strongest helpers, and the belief that Eskimo shamans turn into wolves and Lapps into bears or reindeer. The story of the Netsilik Eskimos' helping spirits, «tunraq», and of Iksivalitaq — whom anthropologist Asen Balikci called «the last great Netsilik shaman» — with his seven tunraqs ends the chapter on a vivid ethnographic note.

The chapter's strength lies in its clear structure and concrete examples from dozens of peoples; it makes Eliade's heavy theory accessible. The weak point is the Turkish edition: the author's name appears once as «Nevili Drury», «Western magic» is printed as «Bau büyüsü» and «souls» as «Çan'ları», and the translation is heavy in places. Even so, the chapter is a good guide to grasping shamanism's worldview — a three-layered universe and a shaman who travels between its layers — in a short space.

Reading Experience
  • Ethnographic examples from specific peoples (Evenk, Yakut, Eskimo, etc.)
  • References to Eliade and other anthropologists, notes and a select bibliography
  • Excerpts from interviews with shamans
  • Black-and-white illustrations
Content Warning
The «Sacred Plants» chapter describes the ritual use of psychoactive plantsThe 1996 Turkish translation contains many typographical and translation errors
If You Liked This
Shamanism: The Discovery of Spirit and BodyTaymas Elemes

Approaches shamanism from a Turkic-cultural and contemporary angle — reviewed on our site

Paganism — The Ancient Nature FaithRobby Silver

Explains nature religions close to shamanism and neopagan movements — reviewed on our site

Shinto — Spirits of the AncestorsRobby Silver

On a living religion with animist and shamanic roots — reviewed on our site

Spoiler
How does this part end?
⚠️ The guiding spirits

The section «Guiding Spirits» divides the shaman's helpers into two groups: «familiar» spirits under the shaman's control and more independent guardian spirits. It explains the Siberian shamans' ties with animals such as the bear, wolf and eagle, the Yakuts counting the bull, eagle and bear as the strongest helpers, and the Netsilik Eskimos' helper spirits called «tunraq».

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
The final book in Talia Hibbert's "Brown Sisters" trilogy — a warm, funny contemporary romance following impulsive, chaotic Eve Brown as she searches for her own path against her family's expectations.
4.2 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
Act Your Age, Eve Brown

Act Your Age, Eve Brown

Talia Hibbert · Novel
Reviews
A bestselling thriller by Marc Levy — New York Times reporter Andrew Stilman is stabbed to death during his morning run, then wakes up two months in the past with one last chance to find his killer.
4.3 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Replay

Replay

Marc Levy · Novel
Reviews
Orhan Pamuk's 1990 novel, which the author has called "the hardest but the one I love most" — a lawyer's search for a missing wife across Istanbul turns into a labyrinthine map of the city, language, and identity itself, fusing Sufi letter-mysticism with a postmodern detective structure.
4.6 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
The Black Book

The Black Book

Orhan Pamuk · Classics
Reviews
A short, ironic and strange novel by the German Christine Wunnicke, inspired by the life of Shimamura Shunichi, a real historical figure reckoned among the first neurologists in Japan. Its strongest side is the dry humour built on the illness of fox possession, Charcot's hysteria demonstrations in Paris and the misunderstandings between East and West, and a thought-provoking play on memory. Its weak side is that the layers of time often mix and that it leans on notes. Not for those expecting a classic historical novel; for lovers of strange, light, many-sided literature.
3.9 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
The Fox and Dr. Shimamura

The Fox and Dr. Shimamura

Christine Wunnicke · Novel
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text