Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Novel

Doğruluk mu Sakal mı?

In English: Doğruluk mu Sakal mı? (Truth or Beard)
Penny Reid
Review by: Rafel Əlizadə12 October 20261 min read
A funny, warm romantic comedy set in a small Tennessee town, combining a family secret, a motorcycle-gang blackmail plot and two stubborn people slowly coming to understand each other. Its strongest points are the lively family dynamic of the Winston brothers, the wit of the dialogue and the believable Duane–Jessica pair. Its weak points are the somewhat schematic biker thread in the second half, the number of explicit sex scenes and an ending that solves the gang problem too easily.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Readers who like warm, funny, slow-burn romantic comedies by authors such as Penny Reid, Helena Hunting or Emily Henry
  • Anyone who enjoys sibling relationships, big family tables and small-town atmosphere
  • Readers drawn to stories where the heroine must choose between travel and love
Not a Fit
  • Readers who dislike explicit sex scenes and strong language
  • Anyone looking for serious, realistic drama: the biker thread in the second half is written in a comic tone
  • Readers under 18: the book is marked for adults
How Readers Rate It
Readability 4.2/5 Flowing
Pace 3.4/5 Average
Romance 4.4/5 A lot
44 voters
The opening: a Halloween night, a «sexy Gandalf» and twin brothers
Pp. 7–25 · about 5% of the book (the start of Halloween night). The end of the scene (pp. 25–27) is in the spoiler section; the remaining ≈93% is not opened in this review.

The events begin in the small town of Green Valley, Tennessee, on Halloween, on a Friday night. Jessica James is a twenty-two-year-old maths teacher, the sheriff's daughter, the sister of a police officer. For Halloween she has put on a bearded Gandalf costume, but in a «sexy» version: a short, low-cut one-piece mini dress and high-heeled sandals. The aim is to provoke her father and brother and to amuse herself.

She comes to the jazz night at the town community centre. From her talk with her close friend Claire we learn that Jessica plans to stay here until she has paid off her student loan and then set off round the world; she counts the travel blogger «Fearless Inger» and Leibniz as «heroes». Most of all she has been attached since childhood to Beau Winston: at eight she knew him as the boy who rescued her cat from a tree, and the feeling has not passed in fifteen years.

The Winston brothers are a well-known family in town: six boys and a girl, all with red or brown hair. Beau and Duane are identical twins; Beau always smiles and is sociable, while Duane is sullen and silent. Jessica has been in love with Beau since childhood and feels a strong antipathy to Duane, because he threw a stone at the tree during the cat incident. Now the family's mother Bethany died suddenly four weeks ago, and the town is still in mourning.

Jessica sees Beau in the hall with a small girl (in a Tinker Bell costume) and loses her tongue: every time she talks to Beau she loses her mind, forgets English and mixes Swedish and Swiss. Claire tells her there is nothing extraordinary about Beau that should frighten her so, she should just go and talk. Jessica says «no». Beau comes to her himself, jokes with Claire and tells Jessica «touch my beard». His eyes, voice and changed look disconcert her: this is not the «hero» of her childhood dream but an adult desire.

Beau takes Jessica by the hand and pulls her backstage, into a dark corner of the community centre. There he takes off Gandalf's hat and false beard and puts them on the floor, presses Jessica against the wall and kisses her. Jessica lives this moment as the most powerful of her life, because her sexual experience is slight and she feels such a strong sensation for the first time. This part of the book is an explicit erotic scene, but it is written in a romantic-comedy tone and the consent of both sides is plain.

Reading Experience
  • The language is conversational, and the characters' inner monologue and dialogue are full of jokes
  • Each Winston brother has his own character line: Cletus's logical oddities, Beau's affability, Jethro's past
  • In the second half the biker thread sharpens but the comic tone is kept and the danger is softened
  • The extras at the end (profiles, deleted scene, letter) are offered as a bonus for series readers
  • The sex scenes take up real space but are mostly given as a continuation of the characters' emotional closeness
Content Warning
The book contains explicit sex scenes and sexual jokes, and the language is heavily profaneThreats connected with drug-running and a motorcycle gang, guns and fight scenes (Duane brawls with his brother Jethro, the gang leader threatens punishment with a razor)The gang leader's attitude to women is crude: lines such as «a woman should know her place» and a demeaning attitude are given as part of his character, though the story rejects themHeavy themes include a mother's death, a woman who gave up a child she became pregnant with, and rejection by parentsthis does not affect the content of the book
If You Liked This
Neanderthal Seeks HumanPenny Reid

From the same author's Knitting in the City series, another example of a maths-minded heroine and funny romance

The Love HypothesisAli Hazelwood

Set in an academic world, with a clever heroine and slow-burn romance

Beach ReadEmily Henry

Two different characters drawn together through writing and feelings

Spoiler
The end of the 6%: this is not Beau, it is Duane
⚠️ Pp. 25–27: the end of the scene and the central mix-up it reveals. Do not open it if you do not want to know how the romantic thread is set up.

In the middle of the scene the man stops, pulls back and says «Jessica, I'm not who you think I am, but I've always wanted you, and I can't do this without you knowing who I am». At that moment another man's voice is heard from the other side of the backstage: «Duane, you idiot, are you here?» And Jessica realises that this voice is Beau's, and the man who has just kissed her was Duane.

So the book's central conflict is opened: Jessica has felt the power in the arms not of Beau, whom she has counted a hero for years, but of Duane, to whom she feels antipathy. This is the end of the first 6%, and the question on which the rest of the novel is built is this: a choice between the man of her childhood dream and the man who now truly shakes her.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A classic Christie puzzle in which Poirot investigates the death of a wealthy woman who wrote him a letter, months before dying, hinting her 'accident' wasn't one — with her dog as the case's silent witness.
4.3 / 5
ReviewsTürkanə Əliyeva
Dumb Witness

Dumb Witness

Agatha Christie · Novel
Reviews
A health book from Alejandro Junger — a cardiologist turned functional-medicine doctor — that locates the 'root cause' of chronic illness in gut dysfunction, backed by personal experience and clinical observation, offering a concrete 21+7-day program.
4.2 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Clean Gut

Clean Gut

Dr. Alejandro Junger · Non-fiction
Reviews
Orwell's first novel — weaving together a native official's treacherous scheme and the suffocating racism of a colonial club, this is the first, not-yet-fully-mature but already powerful iteration of the power-and-self-delusion analysis that would reach full form in "1984" and "Animal Farm."
4.3 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Burmese Days

Burmese Days

George Orwell · Classics
Reviews
A short information book on attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) that starts from the concepts of concentration and attention and covers types, diagnosis and common misconceptions: the «myth — fact» chapter and Russell Barkley's 10 rules for parents are genuinely useful, but most of the text is dry and textbook-like, and the bibliography puts esoteric «concentration» books next to scientific sources.
3.5 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Attention Deficit — The Hyperactivity Barrier

Attention Deficit — The Hyperactivity Barrier

Angela Dainty · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text