Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Positive Discipline A–Z

In English: Positive Discipline A–Z: 1001 Solutions to Everyday Parenting Problems
Jane Nelsen, Lynn Lott, H. Stephen Glenn
Review by: İdris Muxtarzadə07 October 20261 min read
An advice book that teaches parents to be «kind but firm» instead of punishing and shouting, and solves everyday problems in alphabetical order. Its strongest quality is that every principle is given with a short real example (bedtime routine, a phone call, homework) so the reader finds ready-made sentences. Its weakness is the size, the repetition and some claims («75% of problems would disappear») given without sources.
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Parents who want to reduce everyday tension with a child (bedtime, morning rush, homework)
  • Anyone looking for a way to set rules and limits without punishment
  • Readers who like ready-made sentences and real examples and open the book when needed rather than reading it through
Not a Fit
  • Readers looking for scientific research, sources and evidence: the claims are given without sources
  • Anyone looking for professional help with severe trauma, suicide risk or sexual abuse: the book does not replace a specialist
  • Readers who want a short, concise book: the edition runs to hundreds of pages
How Readers Rate It
Readability 4.1/5 Easy
Depth 2.6/5 Average
Practicality 4.3/5 A lot
40 voters
Part one: «What Is Positive Discipline?» (Kind and Firm, Acting Instead of Talking, Information Instead of Punishment, Communication, Limits and Routines)
Read: the introduction and 11 of the 27 tools of part one (being kind and firm, deciding what you will do first, showing by action, follow-through, information instead of punishment, communication skills, realistic expectations, family meetings, limited choices, limits, routines) (pp. 14–38 of the Turkish edition). That is about 6% of the book.

Part one compares three parenting styles: the «Boss» (all the power), the overly lenient «Doormat» type (the child is the centre of the universe) and the «kind and firm» parent. The first lean on punishment, the second on rescuing the child, and the third respects both the child and themselves. The authors say many parents feel guilt because they are either too controlling or too lenient. The solution is to change oneself: even a small change in you will affect the child's behaviour.

The principle «decide what you will do first, then do it» is explained through examples. A mother struggling with her 11-month-old during a diaper change falls silent and waits for the baby to stop squirming. Another mother announces that she will say everything once, and gradually the children begin to listen to her more attentively. A father tells his children he is available to help with homework every evening between seven and nine, and says «this time you are on your own» to those who come at 9:30.

Under «Don't talk, show with your actions», the authors say that more than 75% of problems with small children would disappear if parents talked less. Instead, they recommend giving up questions like «Do you want to put on your seat belt?», being able to say «It's time to put our seat belts on», and speaking with eye contact. «Follow through» has six steps: focus attention on the problem, respect the feeling, say what is to be done, find a solution together, explain your feelings and limits, support the decision with action. The main example is Shelly, who disturbs the mother whenever the mother is on the phone.

The section «Information instead of punishment and learning from mistakes» argues that there is no place for punishment in Positive Discipline. According to the authors, punishment creates anger or guilt in a child, and breeds the thought «I am a bad child» or «I'll show you». Examples: when juice is spilled, «let's clean it up together»; when a child plays roughly with the dog, separate them and say «you can wait until you are both ready to play more gently». This part refers to «hundreds of studies» but does not name them.

The section «Develop your communication skills» explains asking «curious» questions (what happened? what did you learn?), reflective listening, naming feelings, keeping the lips closed while listening, and saying «I notice» instead of trap questions. In the example of a child whose bicycle is stolen, the mother accepts the feeling instead of lecturing and leaves room for the child to reach their own conclusion. «Realistic expectations», «family meetings» (weekly, starting with compliments and an agenda, fifteen minutes to an hour), «limited choices» and «limits» (like the railings of a bridge) are also explained.

The last part of chapter one that was read covers natural and logical consequences and routines. A natural consequence is getting wet in the rain; a logical consequence is decided together with the child: to a child who forgets a lunch box, «I'm sorry, maybe your friends will share»; to a teenager who does not fill the tank, no use of the car. For routines, a bedtime chart with photographs is suggested: as the child finishes each task, they paste on their own photo, and the reminder is the question «what's next on your chart?»

Reading Experience
  • Every principle is explained through short real examples and ready-made sentences
  • A simple comparison of parent types («Boss», «Doormat», kind and firm)
  • The question «what did the child learn?» shows the result in each section
  • An introduction that presents the book as a reference you will want to «hang around your neck»
Content Warning
Some figures in the book (for example «75% of problems», or «a 90% drop in discipline problems» at school) are given without sourcesThe book rests on the 2007 edition; advice about technology and screen time may be outdatedSome examples belong to American families and schools
If You Liked This
How to Talk So Kids Will Listen & Listen So Kids Will TalkAdele Faber, Elaine Mazlish

The most widely read practical book on communicating with children

The Whole-Brain ChildDaniel J. Siegel, Tina Payne Bryson

A parenting approach based on the child's brain development

Positive DisciplineJane Nelsen

The authors' classic book that explains the same approach in general terms

Spoiler
The telephone example: what did the mother do, what did the child learn?
⚠️ The main example of the «follow-through» section.

Shelly disturbs the mother every time she talks on the phone, wants to keep talking even when allowed, and if not, pinches, bites or hits the mother. On a calm day the mother sits with Shelly, says she understands the wish, asks together for a way out, then makes a clear plan: when the phone rings she will say whether there is someone Shelly can talk to; if not, Shelly will play with her Legos; if Shelly hits or bites, the mother will go out on the balcony and finish the call there.

When the phone rings, the mother does as she said. When Shelly shouts «I want to talk too», the mother goes out on the balcony and finishes the call with the door closed. According to the authors, Shelly learns from this that the mother's words are serious, that the mother respects herself and the child, that she can take responsibility by cooperating, that sometimes wishes cannot be fulfilled, and learns to compromise.

In other examples the result is unexpected: the mother does not bring the forgotten lunch box, and the child does not starve until evening but, sharing the healthy food that friends do not like, eats better than ever. When eight-year-old Brene has to wait ten minutes away from the pool, the father sits beside her and says «waiting is hard, shall I bring you some lemonade?». The girl first says «no», then asks for orange juice.

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
A 1940 novel by one of Turkey's most beloved authors, about a weak-willed young man who blames every failure of his on the devil inside him — written in plain, conversational prose, but psychologically sharp underneath its simplicity.
4.3 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
The Devil Within Us

The Devil Within Us

Sabahattin Ali · Classics
Reviews
Daniel G. Amen's practical book that promises to prevent, and sometimes reverse, memory loss by identifying «risk factors» and treating them one by one. In the introduction and first chapter that were read, the strongest side is that it shows vividly the importance of memory in life and turns the risk factors into a memorable scheme with the acronym BRIGHT MINDS. The weak side is that some claims («reversing») are over-optimistic, the harsh criticism of conventional medicine and the tone that comes close to advertising his own clinics. Do not change medical decisions without discussing them with your doctor.
3.2 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Memory Rescue

Memory Rescue

Daniel G. Amen · Non-fiction
Reviews
A short romantic thriller set against an ice storm in Maine: army sergeant Gabriel McQueen goes, at his sheriff father's request, to rescue Lolly Helton from a house on the mountain and runs into two drug-addicted robbers. Its strongest qualities are the struggle against nature and dangerous people in a single night, the physical detail of the cold, and two heroes whose past is wrapped in rough teasing. Its weaknesses are the harshness of the attempted sexual violence and the death scenes, a love line squeezed into one night and a hurried ending.
3.7 / 5
Reviewsİdris Muxtarzadə
Ice

Ice

Linda Howard · Novel
Reviews
One of our era's most influential philosophers, Daniel Dennett, collects a set of favorite "thinking tools" in this book — the Preface and Introduction explain how the term "intuition pump" was coined and why thinking tools are sorted into categories like labels, examples, analogies, scaffolding, and intuition pumps; a rare blend of academic rigor and playful, personal warmth.
4.5 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking

Intuition Pumps and Other Tools for Thinking

Daniel C. Dennett · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text