Kitabda Nə Var? Kitabda Nə Var?
Appearance
Join Us
What's in the Book? Discussion About Us
Azərbaycan English ✓ Русский Türkçe
← Reviews
Non-fiction

Sen Yeter ki İste

In English: Wish Successfully — 7 Rules for Turning Dreams into Reality
Pierre Franckh
Review by: Rafel Əlizadə05 October 20261 min read
An updated version of the bestselling book on «wishing correctly» — placing orders with the universe — by the German actor and self-help author Pierre Franckh. The style is light, humorous and full of personal stories, and there are a few sensible ideas about gratitude, positive emotions and stating wishes clearly. But the central claim — that thought is «pure energy» that directly changes matter — is not scientific, and the «physics» section contains crude factual errors. The most troubling idea is that poverty and failure exist «because they were ordered».
Who Is This Book For?
Good Fit
  • Fans of «The Secret» and books on the law of attraction
  • Readers looking for a light, uplifting, motivating text
  • Anyone interested in gratitude and positive-thinking exercises
Not a Fit
  • Readers who value scientific thinking and evidence
  • People in hard circumstances who are tired of being made to feel guilty
  • Those with no patience for esoteric terminology
How Readers Rate It
Readability 4.1/5 Easy
Scientific grounding 1.7/5 Weak
Motivation 3.9/5 High
41 voters
Introduction, «My Story», Rule I «Start Right Away» and, from Rule IV, «A Little Physics» and «A Little Biology»
Read: «What Has Happened Since», «My Story», «Wishing Must Be Learned Too», Rule I in full («A Matter of the Mind», «Ordering a Parking Space», «The Search for Plants», «Michaela's Wish Factory», «What Do Feelings Have to Do with Success?») and, from Rule IV, «A Little Physics» and the start of «A Little Biology» (pp. 12–46, 118–128). About a quarter of the book.

The author begins with childhood. At six, a wish letter written to a guardian angel and hidden away brings the longed-for bicycle, in exactly the right colour and with a bell. At nine comes the urge to test something «impossible»: a leading role in a film, so that «everyone will notice me». That same year the role arrives in the film «Lausbubengeschichten», but the director has the voice dubbed by someone else. The lesson the author draws: «Everyone saw me, nobody heard me» — the wish was not stated precisely. This is the book's best and most honest page, showing with humour why it matters to phrase a wish carefully.

Having turned into a «realistic sceptic» as a teenager, the author years later stumbles on Stuart Wilde's book «Miracles» and remembers the childhood «wish factory». Here the book's central thesis appears: «Wishes come true every day, every second. Ours too, all of them. So do our doubts and our thoughts that we are worthless.» The universe is «a giant mail-order store»: it does not distinguish good from bad, it simply delivers. The metaphor is readable, but for a reader who takes it seriously the consequence is grim: every bad thing that happens to you is your own «order».

Rule I is practical: start with small wishes before big ones, because the mind does not resist small things. The famous example is the parking space: as you leave home you send the universe the command «My parking space is on such-and-such street», and when you arrive there is either a free spot or someone is just pulling out. The author and Michaela say they have had no parking problems for decades; when they forget, they tell each other «you ordered too late». Confirmation bias is plain here: spaces found are «miracles», spaces not found are «forgetfulness». The story of buying cheap palm trees from a bankrupt company is explained by the same logic.

The most valuable part concerns emotions. Drawing on the work of the psychologist Barbara Fredrickson at the University of North Carolina, the author suggests a simple exercise: look around and ask «what do I like here?», then ask «what don't I like here?», and notice how your mood shifts between the two questions. It is a genuinely useful attention exercise. But it is immediately followed by an unsourced figure: «in a positive mood our perceptual filter opens up by as much as thirty per cent».

The weakest part is «A Little Physics». The reasoning «everything is energy, thoughts are pure energy, therefore thought turns into matter» is a meaningless mixture of scientific concepts; the law of conservation of energy, a «law of resonance» and piano strings are offered as «proof» that wishes come true. Worse, the author writes that «Marie and Pierre Curie observed in 1933 how matter can arise from nothing». Pierre Curie died in 1906; those who observed pair production in 1933 were Irène and Frédéric Joliot-Curie, and the particles came not from «nothing» but from energy.

The most troubling sentence is in the same section: «If we live in a world ruled by scarcity, that want exists because we ordered it. Our neighbour lives in abundance because he chases nothing but wealth, while we are left to experience poverty.» This idea presents illness, poverty and unemployment as the result of personal «wrong thinking» and loads readers in hard circumstances with extra guilt. The Turkish translation reads smoothly, though the editing is uneven in places. In the end the pages on gratitude and clear goals may help; the rest should be read with caution.

Reading Experience
  • Light, humorous language full of personal stories
  • Short, simple exercises at the end of each rule
  • Memorable examples of why a wish must be stated precisely
Content Warning
Pseudoscientific claims and factual errorsIndividual blame for poverty and failureLittle heavy content
If You Liked This
The SecretRhonda Byrne

The best-known book on the law of attraction

The Art of Thinking ClearlyRolf Dobelli

A critical antidote explaining confirmation bias and other thinking errors

The Upside of StressKelly McGonigal

An evidence-based book on how mindset affects the body

Spoiler
What does the «convince the mind» rule claim?
⚠️ The «physics» and «biology» sections of Rule IV.

In Rule IV the author turns to physics to persuade the mind to believe in «miracles». If an atomic nucleus were the size of a pea, the electrons would be 170 metres away, so most of what we see is empty space; colours do not really exist, the brain translates vibrations. From this the conclusion follows: matter is energy, energy can be directed, thought is pure energy — therefore our thoughts become matter. By the «law of resonance» like attracts like: wealthy people grow richer because they live in a «field of wealth vibration», and someone in love finds everything else going well too.

The «A Little Biology» section mocks the «stubborn realists» who say «I only believe what I see»: our eyes perceive only eight per cent of the light spectrum, so we miss ninety-two per cent of reality. According to the author, a person living in scarcity has ordered it; «there is plenty of everything, it is simply distributed according to demand». Later chapters cover belief patterns, the question «can we change our genes too?», the exercises «I am beautiful» and «My body is beautiful», and «using the power of the group».

Responsibility. This review reflects the personal assessment of its author, who is responsible for it. As a platform, "What's in the Book?" is not responsible for the content of the review. All rights to the work belong to its author and publisher; the cover image is used for promotional purposes only.

If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.
How Would You Rate It?
Did this review help you decide?
Reviews · 0
Similar Books
Reviews
An impressive sequel in which the Pulitzer-winning author of «The Prize» explains the post-Cold War energy world — Russia's comeback, Caspian oil reaching world markets, the «supermajors», the nuclear dilemma after Fukushima — with a «Caspian Derby» chapter of special interest to readers from Azerbaijan.
4.5 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
The Quest: Energy, Security, and the Remaking of the Modern World (Vol. I)

The Quest: Energy, Security, and the Remaking of the Modern World (Vol. I)

Daniel Yergin · Non-fiction
Reviews
A comprehensive academic work by Hacettepe University archaeologist Halil Tekin, critically revisiting the outdated terminology and chronology used to describe Mesopotamian prehistory up to the emergence of the Sumerian city-states — recognized as the most comprehensive study of Mesopotamian prehistory written in Turkish. This review covers only the opening of Chapter 1 ("Starting Out").
4.3 / 5
ReviewsCavid Mehdiyev
Prehistoric Mesopotamia: New Approaches, New Interpretations, and New Chronology

Prehistoric Mesopotamia: New Approaches, New Interpretations, and New Chronology

Halil Tekin · Non-fiction
Reviews
A love story between the hockey stars of rival universities: fast, funny, with explicit sex scenes and a past trauma carried in the background. Its strongest points are the sharp dialogue of the two leads and the serious handling of sexism and the father-daughter bond. Its weaknesses are the heavily repeated «enemies-to-lovers» pattern, long side threads and an ending that is perhaps too happy.
3.6 / 5
ReviewsAytən Həsənova
Risk

Risk

Elle Kennedy · Novel
Contents
God, Design, and Fine-Tuning — Robin Collins 17 – 58
The Argument from Desire — Caner Taslaman 59 – 100
The Axiological Argument — Enis Doko 101 – 144
The Kalam Cosmological Argument — William Lane Craig 145 – 173
The Evolutionary Argument Against Naturalism — Alvin Plantinga 175 – 226
Reassessing the Fine-Tuning Argument — Richard Swinburne 227 – 256
4.5 / 5
ReviewsRafel Əlizadə
God, Philosophy and Science

God, Philosophy and Science

Caner Taslaman, Enis Doko (ed.) · Non-fiction
Esc — close · ↵ — open
Text