Raising Human Beings
Good Fit
- Parents tired of reward-and-punishment who look for ways to reduce conflict with the child
- Those who want to change how they see recurring daily arguments such as morning routines, homework and screen fights
- Teachers, educators and other adults who work with children
Not a Fit
- Anyone who believes in raising children with a system of reward and punishment: the book rejects this approach
- Anyone seeking a short, ready recipe: the book is built on stories and long explanations
- Families of a child with a serious behavioural disorder: the book does not replace professional support
The introduction sets out the parent's basic dilemma: accepting who the child is and at the same time helping them to handle the academic, social and behavioural expectations of the «Real World». Greene notes that most parent–child conflicts arise when this balance is upset. The book has two aims: that things go well in the relationship with the child and, at the same time, nurturing the more positive sides of human nature — empathy, honesty, cooperation, taking another's perspective and resolving disagreements without conflict.
The author writes about himself: a father of two teenagers and a clinical psychologist for over twenty-five years who has worked with thousands of children (families, schools, psychiatric units, prisons). He applies in this book to all children the «Collaborative & Proactive Solutions» (CPS) approach that he described in his earlier book «The Explosive Child»; there is not much difference between «typical» and «challenging» children, and all have the same need. The stories were inspired by real children and parents, and the chapters alternate between girls and boys.
Chapter 1 opens with a wide historical picture: children used to be brought into the world to carry on the line and help on the farm, «might was right, father knew best». Now children are «real people» and they know it. Many parents get stuck in the «muddy area» between permissiveness and authoritarianism: they want the child to be independent but not make bad choices, not to be harsh but not disrespectful, not to shout but to be heard. Greene answers: «There is no muddy area between the Kingdom of Dictatorship and the Province of Pushover — it is a partnership, and its most important ingredient is cooperation rather than power».
The author maintains: parents have been cooperating with the child since the child was born (when the baby cries they try to understand the cause and adjust according to feedback). A collaborative partnership does not stop the parent from being an authority, but it is not the «old-fashioned» authority but an authority that chooses to influence: what a parent most wants is influence, not control. The chapter ends with the morning scene of a single mother called Denise: three children (Hank, Nick, Charlotte), a half-eaten breakfast, taunting, the dog's food, hurried shouts. Denise wonders «why must every morning be like this?»
- Each chapter opens with the story of a family; the theory comes after the example
- With questions and answers («A collaborative partnership? With my child? Really?») Greene voices the reader's resistance in advance
- The chapters alternate between girls and boys, and the mother and father figures also change
- The author gives the historical view (the status of children) briefly and uses it to explain the confusion of the modern parent
The same author's core book explaining the CPS model at length for children with challenging behaviour
A book on applying the same model in the school setting
A well-known parenting book with practical sample dialogues for communicating with children
At the end of the part read Denise sends her children — a daughter and two sons — off to school, everyone's mood is spoiled, Nick refuses to eat from the bowl the dog food had been put into; Denise finally leaves a few minutes later than usual and wonders why every morning has to be like this: «Wouldn't it ever get easier?» What follows is outside the scope of this review.
If you see a problem, write to us. Publisher, author, rights holder, or just a reader — it doesn't matter. If there's something problematic about copyright in this review, if the review's author has broken the site's rules, or if you simply have a suggestion or complaint, hey@kitabdanevar.com. We'd rather resolve this between ourselves than go to court: we review requests within 48 hours and, if needed, correct or fully remove the review.